Let's not kid ourselves with the whole "Oh, we're much too fussy and demanding to accept low-quality fare like the Olive Garden!" narrative. Far worse chains than Olive Garden have thrived in Ontario, and continue to do so. I remind you all that Pizza Pizza is still the #1 pizza delivery chain here; that's pretty damning if you ask me. And while OG isn't gourmet, or even really Italian for that matter, I rank it parsecs above East Side Mario's. I've only been to ESM about half a dozen times in my life, yet they've managed to served me two of the very worst restaurant meals I've outside of a Golden Griddle location.
I remember the location at Atrium On Bay always being packed. Always. I couldn't believe they pulled the plug on OG in Ontario, but left Red Lobster open.