I can't really say I agree with that myself because of course there's a whole lot west of Keele. The stopover adds almost an hour of travel time if you want to go from Yonge to Martin Grove, when you factor in the time it takes to wait for an Orange bus once you get off, and the detour down Keele.
Couldn't this annoying transfer be one reason why ridership on Orange is so bad? I know I ride my bike rather than endure it.
Maybe YRT should just institute a shuttle bus for York students, rather than forcing everyone else to wait the 15 minute of half-hour ride down Keele and into the slow and winding York U roadways.
Well the biggest problem is that Keele is 2 lanes south of Steeles. I, to this day, have not understood why Toronto doesn't widen this to 3 lanes each side. There is plenty of space for that to happen, and it's definitely needed. Some sort of HOV lane is definitely needed because the buses really get trapped in really dense industrial traffic with all these gas tankers and transport trucks. Once the bus turns into York U, it takes only a matter of seconds for it to pull into the bus stop.
As for trip generators west of Keele, that may be so but not on the current Purple route. I'm talking about how most of the ridership is due to York U students for the current routing of Purple, which terminates at York U. With the old routing, which paralleled Orange beyond York, I'd say maybe 5% or less would stay on beyond York for the remainder of the trip. I'm glad those days are over, as it only created confusion among new riders.
I can easily see ridership to York using Viva drop if they were forced to transfer yet another time just to get to York. Look at it this way: most riders on Viva Purple got to the Purple by transferring from another bus. Highway 7 is not a residential area (sans the brief distance between Warden and Kennedy, which is exactly where the Viva does not even traverse) so most riders have to find their way to a Viva station first. I already take 3 separate routes just to get to York (1 YRT, 2 Viva). It's not the greatest of routes to take, and if I were forced to transfer one more time I would most likely give up and just drive instead. Trust me, I'm not one to appreciate being treated as left overs on a bus route, and I'm sure not many others would either.
So instead of looking at it as York U students inconveniencing others for 15 minutes, I think it's mostly irrelevant because most of the ridership beyond Promenade Mall are on the bus only to get to York anyways, and at that point the bus is usually packed beyond belief. I think Purple is fine the way it is, though unfortunately the extra pointless transfer concept will come into play once the subway is opened. Thankfully I won't be there when that comes around so I wouldn't have to put up with that stupidity.