Several sources told We The Commuters that Andy Byford, the head of New York City Transit who was hired a year and a half ago to turn our subways and buses around, is about to quit his job.
Byford himself told us he just signed a lease on a great new apartment, he loves his job, and he'll "be here until that job is complete."
But when Gov. Andrew Cuomo was asked about this on the Brian Lehrer Show this week, he took nearly two minutes and one follow up question to say he had "confidence" in Byford. And even then, he couched it by saying he had confidence in the heads of Transit, Metro North and the Long Island Rail Road.
Contrast that with City Council Speaker Corey Johnson, who said this week without hesitation that he wanted to be Vice President of the Andy Byford fan club.
So, whether Byford stays for the next 10 years to see his Fast Forward plan all the way through, or if he quits next week to spend more time in that sweet apartment, where does that leave us, the riders who just want our subways and buses in better shape? I asked We The Commuters reporter Stephen Nessen to answer some of those questions.
If Byford quits, how much of his subway repair plan will keep humming along without him?
There's what called the Subway Action Plan, which has been underway since 2017 and has been credited with speeding up trains and improving reliability. But it was Byford himself who set an aggressive targets for New York City Transit of reducing 10,000 delays a month. After hitting that target for nearly half a year, he recently upped it to 18,000 a month.
He also created a program to speed up subway trips by focusing on repairing signals and getting train operators to stick to the schedules. It's not clear that this pace — or focus on how the subways are operated — would continue without Byford.
I know Byford has said that adding and repairing station elevators is a major priority. Will that still be the case if he leaves?
The fact is, prioritizing elevators or elevator repairs had not been a strong point at the MTA. The governor embarked on a $1 billion plan to improve dozens of subway stations, but it didn't include installing a single elevator.
Byford put elevators expansion into his Fast Forward plan, and pledged 50 new stations would have elevators in five years. But, there's nothing legally binding that would force the MTA to make good on his pledge. In fact, the last time the MTA was legally forced to install elevators was 1979, when a judge ordered 100 accessible stations by 2020. Right now, there are 125.
There are also currently four lawsuits pending over the MTA's lack of accessibility. Plaintiffs are essentially seeking legally binding language that would ensure elevators are installed, regardless of who's in charge.
What's the future of our bus system if he resigns?
Speeding up buses has also been one of Byford's focus points. Ben Fried with Transit Center told me that Byford wasn't the only person at the MTA who cared about improving the bus network, but he came in with a plan, like getting all-door boarding and expanding Select Bus Service.
"To have a person who made that commitment leave the agency before it happens, it would not bode well," Fried said.
Cuomo hired Byford, who was a lauded transit chief in other cities before this, to turn New York's public transportation system around. What's the governor's endgame here, if the rumors are true that he's alienating his own hire to the point of making him quit?
It could be just as simple as, Cuomo would like to take the credit for turning around the subway system.
It’s a bit of a head-scratcher for people who have been following transit closely, since the governor embarked on a long disinformation campaign trying to convince New Yorkers that he doesn’t control the subways. Now, he’s going out of his way to show how much he controls the subways. You can look to his swooping in on the L train tunnel repairs as one example. More recently, Cuomo has been wading into the highly technical field of modern subway signaling. He’s thrown shade at Byford’s plan for modernizing signals using CBTC signals (which is what the L train and 7 train use), saying that’s 1980s technology.
If Byford succeeds, that would mean the subways are running up to international standards, buses are frequent and fast, and the system is fully accessible. Ben Fried told me that if Byford is forced out, "it would be tough to attract someone of Byford's caliber to this position if for some reason he's compelled to leave."
So, seems like you would do as much as you can to support Byford. But that's why you’re not Governor Andrew Mark Cuomo. |
|