AlvinofDiaspar
Moderator
It took them that long just to get to this state?
AoD
AoD
As with many construction projects it is usually the stuff you CAN'T see that takes the most time. Bolting in the actual gates may look major but it's not what takes the time.It took them that long just to get to this state?
AoD
Not sure what is difference between Phase 1 and Phase 2. They've already done 2 of the 3 entrances, and only the west exit to St George Street itself is left. Which I'd have called at least Phase 3.Station St George Station - phase one PRESTO available at all entrances June 14
Station St George Station - phase two PRESTO available at all entrances June 25
I don't really get why people have a problem with them. Yes, they don't operate as fast as the old turnstiles do but they are mechanical and don't operate as fast as someone pushing against a turnstile.Any word on the gates being programmed to open faster?
I don't really get why people have a problem with them. Yes, they don't operate as fast as the old turnstiles do but they are mechanical and don't operate as fast as someone pushing against a turnstile.
I find it's just annoying that you have to stop walking for a second to wait for the gates to open, while in many other places in the world you just tap while walking and the gate opens before you have to stop. Not a huge deal, but could be a much better passenger flow if they open like a half a second earlier.
in some of our stations (like St Andrew that just went live) that would have created a very narrow walk through if the gates extended further out.japan for example has the physical units much longer so that there is time for the computer to detect and make the gates close if theres a no payment. maybe we shouldve picked a unit that was longer so the reader is farther away from the gate.
in some of our stations (like St Andrew that just went live) that would have created a very narrow walk through if the gates extended further out.
I am confident that there is good reason why this particular model was chosen over the longer ones you see in some other places.
I find your question hard to follow.Speaking of St Andrew Station's fare gates, I'm not quite familiar with the station as I've only gone through it twice, but why are there two fare lines on the North and South with entrances and exits on the East and West? Why not have fare lines on the East and West so that there's the option to go to the north or south side escalators/stairs? Is it because the fare collector booth is in the middle of the south fare line and moving it is not worth it?
I mean why are there two fare-paid areas on the concourse level?I find your question hard to follow.
Here is the layout of the station the fare collectors are at, both, the east and west end of the north fare gates.
View attachment 141604
I would guess that it helps with congestion relief at the rush hours......but that is just a guess.I mean why are there two fare-paid areas on the concourse level?