News   Jul 12, 2024
 1.6K     0 
News   Jul 12, 2024
 1.2K     1 
News   Jul 12, 2024
 445     0 

TTC: Flexity Streetcars Testing & Delivery (Bombardier)

You see this a lot in Europe, and yes people adjust to it. I've never entirely figured out the motivation for it though. It's not as if there's some vast energy savings by only opening some doors at stops. At least it's easier than those odd handles you have to flip on German subways in some cities.

I'd actually expect the energy savings to be quite substantial.
 
Sounds like 4409 is coming. One of the two flatcars they've been using for transport arrived in Schreiber from Thunder Bay this morning. Presumably 4409 is on it, enroute to Toronto.

About 6 weeks since the last shipment. Still a lot of work to do to ramp it up to weekly! But it does meet the current delivery schedule. Hard to see how they'll get 2 delivered in August and 4 in September though.

If it was indeed shipped from TB the day before, that would make it 45 days since the last shipment. That matches the 45 day cooldown period preceeding the previous shipment. This would seem to disprove the misguided notion (being pushed by those with agendas) that BBD is increasingly falling behind schedule.
 
Falling behind which schedule? It's certainly well beyond the original schedule that had a delivery every 10 days by now. And it's past the schedule from earlier this year that had it every 15 days by now. Now, it does meet the schedule from June, which had one delivered in June, 1 delivered in July, 2 in August and 4 in September.

But it doesn't give any indication they've managed to ramp up to more than 8 cars a year, rather than the originally promised 39 cars a year, or the currently promised 50 cars a year.

I suspect that if they are only churning out a car every 15 days in December, they'll still be meeting the latest schedule that says they'll only deliver 2 cars in December.

Hopefully though, they'll manage to figure it out soon.
 
Meanwhile, the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA) has exercised its option for an additional 40 streetcars/light rail vehicles from Siemens. They already have a signed order for 175, signed in September 2014. They haven't any vehicles,... yet. Only a life-size model. See link.

IM2015060833MO_072dpi.jpg


Siemens has received an order for an additional 40 light rail vehicles (LRVs) from the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA) in the US for its Muni network.

The order is an option on contract signed by SFMTA with Siemens in September 2014 for 175 LRVs, bring the total number of vehicles to 215.

SFMTA Transit director John Haley said: "The new LRV not only represents our long-term partnership with Siemens but will place their proven superior technology on San Francisco streets.

"The new vehicles are not only sleek in appearance but operate quieter on the rails and will last ten times longer before significant maintenance is required.

"With more 1,300 similar LRVs operating worldwide, the SFMTA is confident our forecasted 260 new vehicles will meet Bay Area transportation and economic needs."

As part of their partnership, Siemens and the SFMTA have recently displayed a life-size model representing a section of the light rail vehicle along San Francisco's Embarcadero.

The LRVs are based on Siemens' S200 model and will be manufactured in Sacramento to meet Buy America requirements for federal funding and the first vehicles are set to be delivered by end of 2016.

Siemens said that approximately 80% of the electricity used by the Sacramento plant for assembly comes from a 2MW photovoltaic installation on the building's roof.

The solar units reduce the facility's carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions by roughly 1,470t a year.

The TTC hasn't exercised its option from Bombardier for an additional 60 streetcars, on top of its current order of 204.
 
Last edited:
The TTC hasn't exercised its option from Bombardier for an additional 60 streetcars, on top of its current order of 204.

I thought they were going to wait until about half the order arrives before they add those. Most likely they will negotiate a reduced cost for those because of the delays to the first batch of them.
 
I thought they were going to wait until about half the order arrives before they add those.
They were going to do it this year, but council didn't provide the funding, pointing out that the option is good until the ... I think it's the 60th car is delivered, which won't happy during 2015.

Most likely they will negotiate a reduced cost for those because of the delays to the first batch of them.
There might be small credits - but that's true whether or not they order more. They'll simply use the option price. If they delay until after the 60th, the cost will go up significantly I'd think.
 
Meanwhile, the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA) has exercised its option for an additional 40 streetcars/light rail vehicles from Siemens. They already have a signed order for 175, signed in September 2014. They haven't any vehicles,... yet. Only a life-size model. See link.
Interesting, I didn't even know they were ordering new vehicles. Their current fleet is not that old...much more modern than Toronto's streetcars. They do have an awfully odd hybrid subway-streetcar system. There are essentially almost no subway-only vehicles. Instead, the vehicles operate as streetcars above-ground and then travel in the subway once sufficiently "downtown". Also interesting is that the vehicles are operator-driven aboveground, but computer driven below-ground. With this model though, the headways are incredibly frustratingly irregular.
 
Yes ... a couple of days faster than the gap between 4407 and 4406. No indication of them ramping up unfortunately.

4409 was likely already on the floor at the time the supply chain issue was still ongoing, so it would be slow like its predecessors.

We will have to see if the next few assemble any faster.

- Paul
 
Interesting, I didn't even know they were ordering new vehicles. Their current fleet is not that old...much more modern than Toronto's streetcars. They do have an awfully odd hybrid subway-streetcar system. There are essentially almost no subway-only vehicles. Instead, the vehicles operate as streetcars above-ground and then travel in the subway once sufficiently "downtown". Also interesting is that the vehicles are operator-driven aboveground, but computer driven below-ground. With this model though, the headways are incredibly frustratingly irregular.

The San Francisco order is for double-ended streetcars. Their current fleet is a mix of double-ended and single-ended. Looks like they are slowly converting over to all double-ended streetcars, and may get rid of their loops.

Toronto is staying with single-ended streetcars on its legacy network. It's going double-ended light rail vehicles for its suburban LRT network, since the Bombardier Freedom models are too wide for the downtown lines. However, they used to have double-ended streetcars along streets like Spadina and Weston, and along the Toronto Civic Railways lines.

Weston_Road_streetcar_-a.jpg


photo-toronto-streetcar-spadina-near-dundas-southbound-note-uniform-note-shopsowitz-sign-on-right-1943.jpg


ttc-2220-bloor-1924.jpg
 
The San Francisco order is for double-ended streetcars. Their current fleet is a mix of double-ended and single-ended. Looks like they are slowly converting over to all double-ended streetcars, and may get rid of their loops..

SF Muni's LRV fleet is all double-ended.
The The E and F-line runs single-ended and double-ended PCC's and other heritage vehicles. The initially meant to be a tourist line while the cable car system was under repair, but was so popular with the locals, it became a legitimate transit line in 1995.
While Market Street Railway is a partner of Muni, it's officially not part of Muni, and doesn't receive any funding. They rely on private donations and memberships to keep the E and F line running.
 
The San Francisco order is for double-ended streetcars. Their current fleet is a mix of double-ended and single-ended. Looks like they are slowly converting over to all double-ended streetcars, and may get rid of their loops.

The only single-ended cars that San Francisco runs are the cars that run on the F heritage line - those cars are not up for replacement. All of their LRVs, past, present and future, are double-ended.

Dan
Toronto, Ont.
 
Better report this to Bombardier top brass.

Staff Review of Options to Exclude Bombardier from Future Bidding

From this report, at this link, for the next TTC meeting on July 29th.

Three possible options:

(A) Prohibition based on poor performance:

As part of the TTC standard procurement practices and included in TTC Bid Documents (e.g. Instructions to Bidders), the TTC expressly reserves the right not to award a specific contract to a company with a poor performance rating history involving the TTC.

(B) Application of Liquidated Damages

The current contract with Bombardier for the supply of new streetcars contains a provision relating to the application of liquidated damages for the late delivery of new vehicles. Currently for every day the Bombardier is late in delivering a new vehicle, provided the delay is not caused by the TTC or a force majeure event, the amount payable under the current liquidated damage provision on a per day per vehicle (which was a genuine pre-estimate of damages the TTC would suffer if the delivery of the vehicles were late), applies. The contract contains an overall cap of 5% of the total contract price on the amount of liquidated damages payable for late delivery.

(C) Termination

A third potential option is the termination of the Contract in accordance with the express terms and conditions of the Contract. This is in addition to the application of liquidated damages.

See the report for more information.
 

Back
Top