I agree! There is no reason to put a street along the lake. People can park a block away and walk to any restaurants or stores along the lakefront. It's not needed at all and it would be a lot more pedestrian friendly and animated to turn it into a public square type space along the lake.
Hard to disagree, but I'll give it a try.
If the City continues to expect/require retail on the waterfront side of this neighbourhood, what with the extreme weather we endure for months on end, freezing cold or boiling hot with a few temperate breaks in between, it's unrealistic to expect customers to hike from QQ to the water. Especially without the long promised but nowhere-in-sight shiny streetcars. Give it a shot on a rainy night or into a north wind in February. You'll likely not want to repeat that experience.
Without access, visibility and some parking, it's a guarantee of failure for retail. Location is otherwise irrelevant. Those who think they can swim upstream against this fact are headed straight to bankruptcy court. Keep in mind, even with all three of the aforementioned ingredients retail has the highest mortality rate of any commercial business.
Humber Bay Shores near Park Lawn and Lake Shore has Marine Parade Drive as its separation between condo towers and the pedestrian pathways. Having a mix of local and visiting customers is only now reaching the point after 20 years where retail can survive and thrive.
If you look west of Yonge, the only waterfront operation that has shown some staying power is Amsterdam's. They offer street and adjacent underground parking or taxi access to their front door. For the rest at Harbourfront where the only choice is to walk, it's lights out for most operators after one very long and barren winter season of empty tables. To expect otherwise is foolish or uninformed.
Conversely, elsewhere around town where the City's obsession has forced retail on the ground floors of every condo tower where there's clearly no market for retail whatsoever has cause many a project to suffer the inglorious fate of empty units or crap that destroys the whole street vista. And let's not forget Aura which is oh so close to some of the most success retail in Canada, yet that retail experiment hasn't got a hope of life even after death.