I wasn't arguing for a particular aesthetic.
I'd be happy to see a well executed Art Deco skyscraper; but not on top of Victorian heritage buildings.
Do note, that I clearly opposed building out the tower proposed above.
I'd further add, I would be interested to see an attempt at a Victorian highrise (done well); but I don't want to tear down existing heritage to get there.
***
Like many I like 1140 as a proposal. I don't know why you would assume otherwise.
But I would note, 1140, the heritage property was built in 1930, so Deco is a logical style for something built above.
The Front Street row dates from ~1870, certainly long before Deco.