"The tops of these towers are the height of pretension."
I somewhat agree with your statement, interchange42.
In a way, we are all pretending to be something that we are not, not just architecturally, but human in general.
I forgot where I read this from, modern architecture always what to be something that it's not. A modern church would look more like a warehouse than a traditional church with domes and buttresses.
I think the problem with modern architecture is that we are still in search for it's own meaning. However, the pace of modern age is so fast that it fails to settle down and really think for itself a style that can truly represent itself. Or maybe, this failure of identifying a "face" or uncertainly to know and understand what we really want is essentially the definition of modern era. I guess, it's something that Derrida also said in his deconstructionist theory. Well, I am not even sure now!
It looks like these Rosewood buildings is pretending to be something traditional, but it's not. But the question is, some of us do feel like living in an "traditionalish" building. A good example is those houses in Woodbridge that try to be something classical Italian. Another example is the New York Towers that give the purchasers feeling of living in New York. Why do you think most of the Seniors Developments look like resort hotels of Europe??
At the end of the day, we should ask what's the responsibility of a building - in this case - a residential tower. Does it serve its purpose when it provides an efficient or "well worth the money" suite layout that the dwellers live comfortably. Or is it more important for the building to serve the City before the dwellers?? It's a very philosophical question I guess....
I believe this forum should also discuss the internal "health" of a building - i.e. the Suite Layouts, the Amenity spaces, or outdoor recreation facilities. I think we have focused too much energy talking about how a building look in a city. We should also spend some effort in discussing what should a building be.
Don't you agree?