News   Nov 22, 2024
National Housing Day: City of Toronto and Riverdale Co-op Open Affordable Homes
 716     1 
News   Nov 22, 2024
Bauhaus Condos Rising in Toronto's Old Town
 1.3K     5 
News   Nov 22, 2024
49-Storey Waterfront Tower Proposed at Spadina and Queens Quay
 3.3K     8 

Ontario Northland/Northern Ontario Transportation

There may be other reasons why ONR got their own track analyser. Maybe it’s necessary for the route to Moosonee, where some of the track is built on muskeg and especially prone to climate change.

Simply acquiring a used piece of technical equipment may just be an indication of nothing.
 
ShonTron said:
There may be other reasons why ONR got their own track analyser. Maybe it’s necessary for the route to Moosonee, where some of the track is built on muskeg and especially prone to climate change.

Simply acquiring a used piece of technical equipment may just be an indication of nothing.
Click to expand...
It's cheaper than building it themselves and they don't have to pay CP or CN to do it for them.
 
Fritter said:
They replaced the platform benches at Gravenhurst station, it must be a sure thing that the Northlander is returning soon!
Click to expand...
Is that station still open? They are going to need to bring the station washrooms and ticket areas to working condition. To avoid this they could use mobile trailers as ticket booths and waiting areas. That might be cheaper.

Do they even have enough rolling stock to run the train?
 
Bordercollie said:
Is that station still open? They are going to need to bring the station washrooms and ticket areas to working condition. To avoid this they could use mobile trailers as ticket booths and waiting areas. That might be cheaper.

Do they even have enough rolling stock to run the train?
Click to expand...
It's owned by the town. It has had a number of facilities in it over the years. I think a vet clinic is currently a tenant in part of it.

Replacing a couple of platform benches might be indicative of something monumental, or indicative that the benches needed replacing.
 
lenaitch said:
It's owned by the town. It has had a number of facilities in it over the years. I think a vet clinic is currently a tenant in part of it.

Replacing a couple of platform benches might be indicative of something monumental, or indicative that the benches needed replacing.
Click to expand...
Funny that Bracebridge and Huntsville stations are not located downtown. Gravenhurst and Party Sound are right downtown. Hopefully this new train service will allow people to travel between those cities without having to drive. Too bad Barrie is not along the way since it is the largest urban city before Toronto.
 
ShonTron said:
There may be other reasons why ONR got their own track analyser. Maybe it’s necessary for the route to Moosonee, where some of the track is built on muskeg and especially prone to climate change.

Simply acquiring a used piece of technical equipment may just be an indication of nothing.
Click to expand...
Good point. It would not just be the route to Moosonee. I had an uncle who worked on portions of the Ferguson Highway (pre-cursor to Hwy 11 north of North Bay) and there were tales of equipment disappearing into the muskeg overnight. They might have determined that with a changing climate impacting on the roadbed, annual of bi-annual analysis wouldn't cut it and scheduling and paying for more frequency would likelybe prohibitive.
 
Bordercollie said:
Funny that Bracebridge and Huntsville stations are not located downtown. Gravenhurst and Party Sound are right downtown. Hopefully this new train service will allow people to travel between those cities without having to drive. Too bad Barrie is not along the way since it is the largest urban city before Toronto.
Click to expand...
The original Bracebridge station is long since razed and the kiosk that served as the ONR stop is (was) one short block off the the main drag of Manitoba St. As far as I know, the kiosk is where the original station was, or darned close.

The 'urban area' of Hunstville is centred in a crook of the Muskoka River but the station is only a couple of blocks away. I guess the town was there before the rail went through.

I would argue the (former) Bracebridge ONR station is closer to its downtown than either of Via's Parry Sound stops, certainly the eastbound (CN) station.
 
What was the service demand when the train was running? Would it be more economically efficient to use some sort of DMU trainset (new or used) then go back to running massive old freight locomotives?
1666279664405.png
 
ShonTron said:
There may be other reasons why ONR got their own track analyser. Maybe it’s necessary for the route to Moosonee, where some of the track is built on muskeg and especially prone to climate change.

Simply acquiring a used piece of technical equipment may just be an indication of nothing.
Click to expand...

True, but the timing is a little fishy.

Fritter said:
They replaced the platform benches at Gravenhurst station, it must be a sure thing that the Northlander is returning soon!
Click to expand...

Why would they replace the benches? To serve the buses?

Bordercollie said:
Is that station still open? They are going to need to bring the station washrooms and ticket areas to working condition. To avoid this they could use mobile trailers as ticket booths and waiting areas. That might be cheaper.
Click to expand...

AFAIK no part of the interior can be used.

Bordercollie said:
Do they even have enough rolling stock to run the train?
Click to expand...
Short answer - maybe. They might have some old cars that could be refurbished sitting in Cochrane.

LemonCondo said:
What was the service demand when the train was running? Would it be more economically efficient to use some sort of DMU trainset (new or used) then go back to running massive old freight locomotives?
View attachment 433705
Click to expand...
If it can meet NA crash standards, it could be an option.
 
micheal_can said:
True, but the timing is a little fishy.



Why would they replace the benches? To serve the buses?



AFAIK no part of the interior can be used.


Short answer - maybe. They might have some old cars that could be refurbished sitting in Cochrane.


If it can meet NA crash standards, it could be an option.
Click to expand...
The trains on the UP express and the FIRTS meet FRA standards. GO transit might be ordering some FLIRT cars so maybe there is a chance to tack onto that order.
 
LemonCondo said:
What was the service demand when the train was running? Would it be more economically efficient to use some sort of DMU trainset (new or used) then go back to running massive old freight locomotives?
View attachment 433705
Click to expand...
The problem with DMU's is that they need more maintenance and if it's a fixed trainset then you cant swap out cars for maintenance. The whole train has to be taken out of service.
 
You must log in or register to post here.

Back
Top