It is hard to tell from the architect's sketch how nice it will look, as the choice of exterior materials used will have a big effect...
Thanks for the photos, SimonP. Now I'm fascinated by the history of this "mystery structure" at 1864. Averagejoe, what made you think it isn't a house? Could it be a house that fell into disrepair and has been abandoned? I wonder when the taller apartment building on the right of the photo was built - it looks fairly modern so I was surprised that it too will be demolished.
I worry too about the precedent that is set if the extra stories are approved. I am not familiar with the history/politics of the height bylaw along this part of Queen, but if exceptions start being granted routinely, then why not change the bylaw (is it there to make sure that any buildings allowed to exceed the height restriction are vetted as being architecturally "exceptional" enough to be worth it)?