News   Jul 16, 2024
 673     0 
News   Jul 16, 2024
 596     0 
News   Jul 16, 2024
 734     2 

Toronto Icestorm of 2013

Some trees like Willows can lose most of their branches and do okay. There's a willow in my backyard that's lost around a quarter of its branches- I see it bouncing back this spring. No so much so for another, less resilient tree beside it- I think it won't make it past the next year.

Case in point: the huge willows on the Yonge side of Mt Pleasant Cemetery that were shredded in the windstorm of fall '12. They looked like goners; yet after a good pruning, they're still kicking (though I don't know what effect this present ice storm's had)
 
Posted back in 2011 but still true for all the same reasons.

Buried utilities versus aerial infrastructure.

As a retired Bell engineering manager whose duties included the design of facilities to be placed in new subdivisions and rural applications as well as urban renewal projects I know a thing or two about all those poles and wires that blot out the sun in some locations.

1960 was indeed a watershed year that saw the trend towards building less aerial infrastructure and more buried plant, both Bell and Hydro and later Cable TV in all three scenarios.

In new subdivisions the parties shared the same trench and lateral run-offs to the homes, all the digging was done by machine and there were no driveways or sidewalks in the way. The ongoing advantage of fewer storm or other damage was a sweetener.

Rural locations were reinforced by placing buried cable in the boulevard/ditch instead of adding another cable to a pole line that was possibly too far gone to stand the strain of another cable. The cable was placed by one or more bulldozers that forced a plowshare down 3 feet and laid the cable through it. This method was a little less than exact in the route of the train and the cable it laid was not all that straight and parallel to the fence line as designed . A right of way for a second cable 5 or 10 years later was rarely forthcoming from the municipality so it was back to poles and aerial construction.

Rebuilding aerial plant in the urban environment poses many problems. A lot of downtown Toronto Telephone and Cable service was originally placed in back lanes on poles, the Hydro service was and still is in the front street. Buried front street construction to replace aged or inadequate aerial services would be incredibly expensive for two reasons. The shared trench location in the boulevard area usually assigned to such utilities is about 12 feet back of the curb on most inner city street profiles, take a look out your window at that location. I bet it is full of trees ,gardens, driveways, parking pads etc, the City requires contractors to tunnel these features rather than machine cut and fill. To access the same point on your home that your meter or telephone/cable service wire enters is probably a bigger nightmare than the trench down the street.

Bottom line, too expensive and intrusive to private property owners. Imagine one home owner on the street who refuses entry to their property , and he or she is there believe me, and the entire project is dead in the water.
 
YOU can pay, coming out of your own pocket, to bury the electrical, cable, and telephone lines from the poles to your house. That would leave the wires still on the poles on your street, but your own connections would be buried. Still expensive, for you, to do that, but at least you'll be ahead of the others on your street.
 
It is now time to push and push for the wholesale burial of our electrical infrastructure. Montreal and most of Quebec did the same after the 1998 ice storm and we should follow their lead.

There is absolutely no reason aside from typical Toronto penny-pinching and myopia why the bulk of our critical electrical infrastructure is dangling above rotting wooden poles. Not only is it disgusting to look at, but it is clearly a public safety issue.

I haven't had power since Sunday at 3AM. Our house is freezing cold, no fireplace, no gas stoves.. We have no way of doing anything. Thank God for friends and neighbours nearby who still have power, otherwise I'd be worried.

Think about the costs!

It's an absolutely disgrace that 99% of the power lines in this city and the whole GTA is not buried.
 
I think my proposal is by far and large the only reasonable way of doing it, implying a timeline of 50-100 years or so ... i.e. when roads are rebuilt bury them!
 
While, according to the gospel of Rob Ford, the amalgamated City of Toronto did not have a state-of-emergency, it was for the many individual neighbourhoods that were hit. In fact, I think, the pre-amaglamated City of Scarborough may have declared itself in a state-of-emergency, while the pre-amalgamated City of Etobicoke may not have done so.
 
YOU can pay, coming out of your own pocket, to bury the electrical, cable, and telephone lines from the poles to your house. That would leave the wires still on the poles on your street, but your own connections would be buried. Still expensive, for you, to do that, but at least you'll be ahead of the others on your street.

My house was built in 1964. All lines/cables were buried when my house was constructed. There are no wires on any of the poles on my street.
 
It's too expensive and intrusive but yet other places are able to do it.

exactly! where there's a will there's a way!

I hate all the procrastination and dithering. Sometimes things simply have to be done. I don't want to hear about "private property" -- some things supersede this.
 
I was not staying at my apartment, I was with someone else and his place lost power around 3 am on Saturday and Got power back yesterday afternoon. Our house was frigid.
 

Back
Top