Stinson ponders move to U.S.
Canada not place for original ideas, developer says
Chris Wattie, National Post
Published: Tuesday, September 04, 2007
Harry Stinson says he has all but given up on the city he helped to build.
One week after a court ruling forced the colourful developer out of One King West in Toronto, the landmark building he now admits was "my obsession," Mr. Stinson says he is already thinking of moving on and leaving the country.
"I'm looking at leaving Toronto, I'd say Canada altogether," he says wearily, leaning back in the plain office chair that is one of the few pieces of furniture in the tiny studio office where he has worked since a court order placed a receiver in charge of One King West.
Email to a friend
Printer friendly
Font: ****"I'm very interested in opening up in the States. Even with the credit crunch that's on there now. If you have a legit business project, then there are thousands of financing options. And they're willing to say: 'Hey, I like that idea. Let's look at this; let's look at it on its merits.' "
And the often controversial Mr. Stinson, once hailed as the condo king of Toronto, says that the fate of his beloved condominium hotel project is an object lesson in what happens to innovative projects in this country. "If one wants to be an entrepreneur, with original ideas, Canada is the wrong country to be born in," he says. "This country focuses on telling you why you can't do something."
Mr. Stinson's creditors beg to differ. The ambitious One King West project, a combination condominium and hotel built around a heritage property on one of the busiest corners in downtown Toronto, is now awash in debt and a tangle of lawsuits, claims and accusations.
David Mirvish, who provided the bulk of the financing for the project, finally sought a court order this summer to put a receiver in charge of One King West after months of negotiations and missed payments on more than $10-million owed him by Mr. Stinson.
The 575-unit building, constructed around a historic pub and bank building on the corner of Yonge and King streets, was already in bankruptcy protection but Mr. Stinson continued to run the hotel operations of the project, working almost around the clock and often living in its upscale rooms. "It was night and day," he says.
"I was the front-line guy ... if a hotel guest got locked in the bathroom, I had a tool chest. If a car broke down, I would go and help start it ... I knew where everything was in the building, I could jump into virtually any job.
"Christmas Eve last year, I was cooking, 'cause we had a huge run on the room service because all the restaurants were closed."
But financial difficulties mounted. An April 20 agreement had given Mr. Stinson until the end of July to settle his $10.4-million debt with Mr. Mirvish, but he was unable to come up with the funds.
Last month, the theatre impresario turned real estate investor appears to have lost patience with his former partner and Mr. Mirvish went to court to ask that a receiver be put in charge of One King West. On Aug. 24 a judge agreed, placing all four Stinson-owned companies -- Stinson Hospitality Inc., Dominion Club of Canada Corp., and the two companies that operated the hotel part of the project and all their assets -- in the hands of a court-appointed trustee.
pg2
It also ordered Mr. Stinson to vacate the property he had worked on and helped to run since it opened in August, 2005.
For the first few days after the ruling, Mr. Stinson says he was in a fugue state. "It has been numbing ... to be wrenched out of something you've been working on for 11 years," he says. "It's like you've been taken in one of those Star Trek transporter machines and you're in limbo. You're physically in the same city, but it's a totally different environment."
The financial woes of One King West and the collapse of another high-profile Stinson project, the 165-metre Sapphire Tower that was to be built near Bay and Richmond streets, left hundreds of smaller investors and tradesmen holding millions more in debts but Mr. Stinson blames the failure of One King West on under-financing and lack of imagination in Canada's financial industry.
Email to a friend
Printer friendly
Font: ****"The Achilles heel that is still unsolved is the legal [and] financial structure of the building. There are reasons why it was structured the way it was structured. But in the end, because the structure of the operation was so unique, the financial industry and the legal community did not, and still does not, understand it," Mr. Stinson says, running a hand through his perpetually tousled hair.
"The problem is that we don't really have a hotel there, in the conventional sense ... and we're not structured conventionally."
He pauses thoughtfully. "I keep saying 'we' as if I was still there," he adds.
The more than 400 condominiums at One King West available to use as hotel rooms were not owned by the hotel, but were instead leased from unit owners who let the hotel rent them out to guests when the owners were not using them. The result, Mr. Stinson says, was "really more like a kibbutz than a hotel."
Despite his public, often bitter courtroom battle with Mr. Mirvish, he says his former partner deserves much of the credit for getting One King West built.
"One King West owes its existence to David Mirvish's role, for better or worse," he says. "It would never have been built without him. I'm obviously disappointed how it's turned out for me, but the building got built and the hotel's turned out to be quite a dynamic operation.
"We both, still, can look at it and say: 'Wow. What a great building.' ... We created a landmark."
Mr. Stinson acknowledges that he is essentially broke, but hopes the sale of the land where Sapphire Tower was to be built will allow him to repay his investors. But he does not expect any profit from his final project, High Park Lofts in Roncesvalles Village, which is close to occupancy but which he says cost too much to complete.
And he admits that he cannot yet bring himself to even look at One King West.
"It was 11 years and at the end, to come away with nothing and millions and millions in personal debt. It's really difficult to be philosophical about that or even understand it.
"What did all that get me? It just doesn't seem right."
cwattie@nationalpost.com