News   Jul 16, 2024
 186     0 
News   Jul 16, 2024
 321     0 
News   Jul 15, 2024
 1.1K     3 

Seven ways to make Toronto a world-class city again

TLDR: late-twenty-somethings have existential crisis upon realizing there are no world class cities; and that moving to a tiny condo in downtown Toronto and fetishizing every mass-produced global food/music/tech/style trend they could find on the internet made them more generic and boring people than before they came.

Haha. I wouldn't paint with quite as broad a brushstroke myself, but it's a point well made: you can't buy greatness. You've got to look at your DNA and build on what you do well. In Toronto, I'd say its strongest organic asset is its neighbourhood identities. That's something the city can build on, and I sincerely hope the Powers That Be keep that in mind when it comes to zoning, transit planning, permitting etc.

PS. Love your tag line. Reminds of a line from an old BBC miniseries, "A Very British Coup," about the election of a socialist prime minister in the U.K. and the conspiracy among power brokers to bring him down. Great scene at the start as the PM takes the train from his home in Sheffield to London. A reporter puts a mic in his face and asks "Is it true you plan to abolish first-class rail travel?" PM: "Oh no. I'm going to abolish second class. I think all people are first class, don't you?" He then offers her a potato chip.
 
TLDR: late-twenty-somethings have existential crisis upon realizing there are no world class cities; and that moving to a tiny condo in downtown Toronto and fetishizing every mass-produced global food/music/tech/style trend they could find on the internet made them more generic and boring people than before they came.
I don't think they do realize it. And it's worse than boring, it's the blanket mediocrity and sameness of this existence.

Facebook is running an ad currently about a young girl in India who is shown dancing, learning through watching and meeting others, actually talking and being with her parents and large family. Then it cuts to a narrator who says the girl has lots, but is deprived of the internet, and we should imagine how better her life would be if she was online and of course on Facebook. As a 44 yr old Gen Xr I well remember life before the internet and certainly before Facebook, so my reaction to the ad was that the girl is better off without FB.
 
This is a problem that can't be solved by the same means which produced it, so let's change the conversation.

Let's all stop defending or arguing whether Toronto is or isn't one and let's talk about Toronto as a world class city.

I'll start with a simple question: what are your favorite things about living in a world-class city? Something's keeping your here, no doubt, but what are you most proud of and what do you enjoy the most here? What is something only YOU know about this place?


For me, it's the ability to stroll in shorts and flip-flops through Kensington in the morning and attend a suit-and-tie event in the evening. Here I am a social chameleon, welcomed everywhere, fitting in everywhere, standing out in my own way. I love that and would not trade it for anything.
 
Last edited:
Let's continue the thread on what makes Toronto great. Here are my top 10:

1)Its a walkable city core.
2)City is constantly improving slowly but surely. Yes our public realm is slummy but it is improving. Bloor looks a lot better. queens Quay and our Waterfront are a lot better now than in 2000.
3) Public transit is in the midst of huge expansion. As much as we hate the TTC delays. The reason we do is because transit is SO important in Toronto because it is so heavily used. This is something to be proud of. Improvements are coming. York subway extension, new airport train, new streetcars, new subway trains, a huge new Eglinton line, Scarborough subway (for better or worse), smart track, GO expansion and regional express rail. Name a city with so much current transit investment? Assuming it all gets built, Toronto will be a whole lot better to get around.
4)Ravines. Green spaces in the city to feel immersed in nature. Sure we don't have fancy landscaped European parks, but we have lots of green space. Lots of private large mature trees in neighbourhoods. A visitor from London was once working with me from Yonge and Sheppard tower and asked if all that green past the towers was a massive park. I said no, it is all residential houses beneath those trees.
5)Bustling yet quiet. Sure our main streets are loud, but walk a block into a neighbourhood and listen to the birds chirp and all the peace and quiet.
6)amenities galore. Downtown is chock full of amenities. Lots of grocery stores with food choices from around the world. Stores catering to any taste, culture.
7)A growing Cafe and patio culture - more people outside eating and enjoying the city life.
8)Safe and ability to walk pretty much anywhere without fear.
9)Toronto Islands. Taking a ferry to another world. It's not glamorous, but it's a huge park that you can be downtown and feel like you are in the cottage country.
10)Food culture to eat any food from anywhere in the world.

To balance, here are 10 I think should be improved in the next 10-20 years:
1)More family housing. We should focus less on building tiny condos or McMansions and force developers to build residential for all life phases including growing a family. We need larger but affordable condos, more town homes, more mid-rise buildings, more rentals. We don't need that many fancy condos with huge amenities that few use but more functional buildings with community centres and public amenities
2)Better public realm. Let's start a program to start burying utilities and plant street trees along major streets. One major street at a time. Perhaps start downtown and expand to major urbanized/commercial streets to encourage more pleasant walking experience.
3)More reliable transit. Expansion is great but if trains don't run or fail weekly that is a huge problem.
4)More parks downtown. We need a large green space downtown. With all the urban growth, Toronto downtown needs some concrete relief. Perhaps dedicate a huge block and make it a park. Perhaps bury the railways/Gardner and make a park over it.
5)City and Civic pride. A sense of pride to live and be a Torontonian. Stop comparing us to New York, London, etc. we are Toronto. We should be a me too city. We should be unique and different.
6)Follows #5, but to me pride means a cleaner city. Toronto is dirty and trash everywhere. People leave garbage in parks, on the streets and in our communities. It's sad to see. The city should do a better job cleaning up and citizens should help keep city cleaner.
7)Expand the Waterfront improvements and build the QQE LRT. It's past due. Make Queens Quay East a model transit oriented community.
8)Implement a traffic tolling system. We need to reduce the number of cars in this city. Charge a toll to use expressways or to travel during peak times. See Stockholm as a model.
9)Encourage downtown style urbanization in the suburban centres. NYCC is doing well but it's too residential. We need to make each suburban centre as a commercial and office hub. Perhaps offer low or no tax to encourage office or mix use development beyond just ground retail and condos.
10)Build an absolute landmark building for a Toronto Museum that showcases our history and the migration and waves of immigrants and how each group influenced the cities growth. Make it a dynamic museum that showcases not just the history but projects what the current trends are. Perhaps a landmark building on the waterfront.
 
10)Build an absolute landmark building for a Toronto Museum that showcases our history and the migration and waves of immigrants and how each group influenced the cities growth. Make it a dynamic museum that showcases not just the history but projects what the current trends are. Perhaps a landmark building on the waterfront.

Haven't heard much on that front.

Well, if you talk to Howard Moscoe, the former Ward 15 (Eglinton-Lawrence) councillor who spearheaded the proposal prior to his 2010 retirement, he'll tell you it's merely in stasis. "We're biding our time and waiting for Mayor Ford to disappear," he says in late August.

https://nowtoronto.com/news/museum-mystery/
 
Excellent reframing of the topic at hand. Speaking of Toronto Museum - there is an article in the Saturday Globe:

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...museum-thanks-to-this-couple/article23787574/

Ms. Blake says that given the star-crossed history of the project, she and her husband decided to take a different approach. Instead of fixating on where to put a museum, they want to start by building an organization and gathering momentum. The building can come later.

In the meantime, the Museum of Toronto will work on Web resources, pop-up history events and other tactics for reaching a wide audience, including youth.

Ms. Blake doesn’t want the project to appeal only to the blue-rinse set or moneyed downtowners. She doesn’t want to it to be all about the War of 1812 or John Graves Simcoe, either.

The stasis - at least on the building front - will be with us for awhile yet.

As to the matter of what makes Toronto great - the tangible, physical aspects are important (and I won't repeat them), but let's not forget human and monetary capital. I could be wrong, but Toronto seems like a place that will able to retain local talent and even attract established international ones far better than days' past. There is also the matter of international reputation - Toronto may no longer be New York run by the Swiss, but I do think we have gotten more relaxed, exciting - and dare I say more relevant than ever.

AoD
 
Last edited:
Excellent reframing of the topic at hand. Speaking of Toronto Museum - there is an article in the Saturday Globe:

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...museum-thanks-to-this-couple/article23787574/



The stasis - at least on the building front - will be with us for awhile yet.

As to the matter of what makes Toronto great - the tangible, physical aspects are important (and I won't repeat them), but let's not forget human and monetary capital. I could be wrong, but Toronto seems like a place that will able to retain local talent and even attract established international ones far better than days' past. There is also the matter of international reputation - Toronto may no longer be New York run by the Swiss, but I do think we have gotten more relaxed, exciting - and dare I say more relevant than ever.

AoD

Old City Hall would be ideal, especially with the courtyard covered. Retrofitting would be crazy expensive though.
 
The Drake effect? More creative and successful people in all fields of endeavour who proudly assert their base and identity in this city. It's relatively new when you think about it. Generations past felt it was unthinkable to maintain a sustainable career while remaining in Toronto/Canada or while projecting too clearly a lack of American cred'. Toronto posing as U.S. cities in movies and tv shows was the manifestation of something that ran a little deeper, culturally speaking... or clinging to French Canadian-ness for anything that would mark us as 'other' with respect to the America. We really needed to break free of all this to individuate in any meaningful way. Thanks Drake. Thanks TIFF. Thanks....
 
. Thanks....

Wayne and Shuster. Never left Toronto despite offers to move to the US and the most appearances on the Ed Sullivan Show. Canadian style humour (albeit pretty corny at times), poking fun at ourselves without doing put downs. They were probably the first entertainers who were popular in the US that didn't leave the country. They were proud Torontonians to their last day. Frank's brother Joe has a street named after him, Johnny and Frank have a Heritage Toronto plaque.
 
Last edited:
The non-existence of a Toronto museum speaks to the problem here; the average person has little concern for how Toronto is viewed by other people in the world. Most people just want a nice life for themselves, and aren't willing to pay for showpieces that confer no tangible benefit to people who live here. There's little civic pride or desire to promote the city as a tourist destination, so we end up with a shabby public realm and few major draws for outsiders. Most people don't think that the city is particularly unique or has a history worth celebrating.

In contrast, tourism is a large part of the economy in other cities like London, Paris or NYC so they have a more direct interest in spending money on the public realm and cultural institutions. Tourism is Toronto is increasing, but it's not at the point where the average resident recognizes the value in spending money to attract more visitors.
 
Dispersion of political power in Canada is also a factor that inhibits Toronto's position in the world; many global cities are also national capitals. Thanks to a historical quirk, our national capital and it's parliament buildings, supreme court and national cultural sites are located in a relative backwater instead of the country's largest city. People go to London to see the British Museum, but they also visit the official residence of the Head of State (Buckingham Palace) and parliament buildings all in one place.

In a sense Toronto punches above it's weight as a provincial capital in a small country...
 
Last edited:
Dispersion of political power in Canada is also a factor that inhibits Toronto's position in the world; many global cities are also national capitals. Thanks to a historical quirk, our national capital and it's parliament buildings, supreme court and national cultural sites are located in a relative backwater instead of the country's largest city. People go to London to see the British Museum, but they also visit the official residence of the Head of State (Buckingham Palace) and parliament buildings all in one place.

In a sense Toronto punches above it's weight as a provincial capital in a small country...

Also another thing to keep in mind is that Toronto is relatively new - and it wasn't even the premier Canadian city until the last 40 years. In many ways, Toronto is just starting to get out of Montreal's shadow in terms of self-identity.

AoD
 
Last edited:

Back
Top