The city needs a decent beach? What about the eastern beaches, Cherry Beach, the Toronto Islands, the western beaches, and the urban beaches such as Sugar Beach? I do, however, agree that the parklands could use more attractions, and I think that a stadium could be great for the area, though Rob Ford (and suburban American-oriented football leagues) would probably want huge parking lots for tailgate parties.
When I look at this plan, I think that they should also extend the transformation to Keele Street, and include a plan for redeveloping the underdeveloped stripmalls and housing on the west side. It would be great to see strong midrise streetscape of mixed-use buildings with commercial space on the ground floor on both sides of Keele.
I personally, don't think any of those beaches are very nice. I might have higher standards than some people on this site. I don't want trees, bushes, twigs, plants, weeds, stones, leaves and other objects, in the sand. (and especially not dog poop) How about umbrellas, lounge chairs, showers, rental stores, a nice restaurant, a cafe and all the services that great beaches have? (Think South Of France) Besides that, the water is too cold for most people. There is also the perception that the water is polluted. Yes, we know that's not the case but the reality is, very few people go into the water.
At Montreal's man made lake, you'll see lots and lots of people in the water, including children. The water temperature is quite nice all summer long. It would be nice to have a clean, shallow lake, with a great beach. (nice, clean sand) That way the water could warm up faster or even be heated. People could swim from May to September.
Let's face it, our beaches are fine as parks but in terms of being a world class beach, they suck! Tell any tourist looking for a serious beach, to go there, and see their reaction. I've brought out of town friends to the Beaches and none of them were very impressed. Sure, the atmosphere in the Beaches neighbourhood, is very nice but who the hell puts a dog run, right on a beach? Get serious. lol Most of the beach is quite scruffy and pretty much left in it's natural state. Some people like that but I prefer a manicured, stylish, well serviced tourist type beach. I'm sure if Toronto had one beach like that, it would be a huge success. (People wouldn't have to trek up to Wasaga)
Come on, we don't even have one single nice restaurant, bar, cafe, store, rental shop or even an ice cream stand anywhere on our beaches. (and by NICE, I don't mean a Pizza Pizza hut)