News   Nov 22, 2024
 735     1 
News   Nov 22, 2024
 1.3K     5 
News   Nov 22, 2024
 3.4K     8 

King Street (Streetcar Transit Priority)

Just in time to turn it off for the TIFF detours. Now if they could use transit signal priority for the detour as well, then maybe I would get some little (very little) pleasure from it.

Then they will report that signal priority doesnt work! Zero street cars wen through king after turning on signal priority!
 
The King St. pilot project is saving downtown Toronto commuters approximately $11.5 million a year in terms of time, a new study has concluded, with the authors recommending Toronto city council make the project permanent.

Ryerson University’s City Building Institute (CBI) released a report Thursday saying that according to their calculations the project saves $10.9 million in time for existing streetcar users and $0.6 million for new users.

From: https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/20...5-million-in-time-per-year-ryerson-study.html

Full Report at: https://www.citybuildinginstitute.ca/2018/09/20/value-of-time-savings-in-king-st-transit-pilot/
 
^This is crucial, as it's from *Metrolinx*...not the City, not the TTC, as Ford will be prone to dismiss any case they make:
“That works out to about 50 cents per trip,” said Graham Haines, CBI research manager.

He said the study used data from the City of Toronto and analyzed time savings using Metrolinx’s standard measurement of $17.36 for each hour of in-vehicle travel time, noting they used the Metrolinx number as the agency “developed a standard methodology for how they evaluate the cost and benefits of transit projects.”
If Ford has a problem with that, he has a problem region wide...
 
The King St. pilot project is saving downtown Toronto commuters approximately $11.5 million a year in terms of time, a new study has concluded, with the authors recommending Toronto city council make the project permanent.

Ryerson University’s City Building Institute (CBI) released a report Thursday saying that according to their calculations the project saves $10.9 million in time for existing streetcar users and $0.6 million for new users.

From: https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/20...5-million-in-time-per-year-ryerson-study.html

Full Report at: https://www.citybuildinginstitute.ca/2018/09/20/value-of-time-savings-in-king-st-transit-pilot/

Doug Ford will ignore the 70 seated people and 181 standing people on board those streetcars and be more concerned about the 1.3 people in the automobiles.
 
Doug Ford will ignore the 70 seated people and 181 standing people on board those streetcars and be more concerned about the 1.3 people in the automobiles.
Yes. Anyone who thinks that Doug Ford will prefer fact over prejudice - especially a prejudice previously and publicly espoused - is trusting in hope over experience.
 
Doug Ford will ignore the 70 seated people and 181 standing people on board those streetcars and be more concerned about the 1.3 people in the automobiles.
Very true since he hates streetcars.

Regardless how bad TTC needs more cars, it will be up to city and the Fed's to find the money for them. Ford will say no to any idea of having more streetcars on the road. The province said no to the current order.
 
Was at Union and King Street last night, saw probably 7 streetcars pass east bound and only 1 west bound . . .
This can certainly happen if there is some sort of disruption/accident and/or when a shift change means cars are going out of service and heading 'home'. If you are trying to report a more serious problem with route management you need more than one (rather vague) report of a personal experience. (For examples of 'scientific' observations take a look at the reports that Steve Munro posts on the King project. (Yes, he does report that the TTC's route management is poor but he identifies where and why bunching occurs.) (Of course, there are no streetcars at 'Union and King' either ....)
 
King St. pilot project saves riders $11.5 million in time per year: Ryerson study

8 months into King Street pilot, police are still having trouble enforcing rules

It seems that the King Street Pilot project will become permanent. It seems that the big problem was left turning vehicles blocking streetcars. The solution is very confusing and not intuitive.
I wonder if they should initiate another trial to see if there is a better way of solving the problem. How about just eliminating left turns, but still allowing through movements?
 
I don't see how that's any more enforceable than 'no straight'. Change the laws to allow enforcement by camera, don't change the pilot.
The point is that is shouldn't rely on enforcement - it should be a solution that is logical and would be supported by motorists regardless of enforcement. Enforcement should be for the ~2% who deliberately violate the rules, not the 25% who don't understand the rules because they are so counter intuitive.
If they knew what needed to be done, then a pilot wouldn't have been needed - they could have just done the right thing right away.
They learned something with this trial, but why not try to learn more. Was most of the benefit derived from preventing left turns, or preventing through movements. Isolate your variables.
 
The point is that is shouldn't rely on enforcement - it should be a solution that is logical and would be supported by motorists regardless of enforcement. Enforcement should be for the ~2% who deliberately violate the rules, not the 25% who don't understand the rules because they are so counter intuitive.
If they knew what needed to be done, then a pilot wouldn't have been needed - they could have just done the right thing right away.
They learned something with this trial, but why not try to learn more. Was most of the benefit derived from preventing left turns, or preventing through movements. Isolate your variables.

There's no way it's people not being able to understand a friggin sign. It's mostly people who think they're too good for the rest of us.
I drive, walk, transit King Street all the time (King is my first love)...I see these chumps.

And if it is confusing to anyone then they really shouldn't be behind the wheel of a tonne of metal and mechanics. End of.
 
I watched a guy today trying to make a left onto a QEW off ramp ... a big no left turn sign, and 3 lanes of cars facing him. Not sure which part he couldn’t understand ....

Part of the problem with King St is that because it’s a pilot, the signage isn’t always clear and typical Toronto, some intersections suffer from serious sign clutter. However, some people could have 5’ high neon lights, and they would still ignore them.
 

Back
Top