Northern Light
Superstar
If they can't live with Erin O'Toole, they definitely couldn't live with Charest. I think it is pretty clear that the red Tories doesn't have a future in the Conservatives.
AoD
Well, I think that depends on Charest's ability to takeover the party.
Its not as if this hasn't been done before, both in Canada and elsewhere.
One of the shortcomings of our system, I would argue, is party leadership races are easily manipulated by who sells the most memberships (gains voters) during a leadership race.
But its one that exists, has been exploited, and certainly could be again.
Would that be ideal, for the Conservatives, or for Canada? I'm not so sure........
Is it 'clean' politics as most would define it, probably not.........but its certainly a plausible path to victory.
Charest would then have to effectively control and edit his caucus, but again, that's do-able.
That its perhaps too easy to do is its own concern.
But I wouldn't rule Charest out prematurely.
Edit to add:
The argument's against Charest's chances, either as leader or successful leader, have more to do with age; and with having left office in Quebec under.....less than ideal circumstances....