News   Apr 01, 2026
 131     0 
News   Apr 01, 2026
 426     0 
News   Apr 01, 2026
 393     0 

VIA Rail

Wonder if they needed CN pilots. I should have bought a ticket just to experience that.
You could still buy a ticket for tomorrow, but there are only two possibilities: either VIA got enough LEs qualified for the York and Bala Sub (Bala Sub is usually only worked by Capreol crews) - or they relied on CN pilots. In any case, crewing issues appear to me as the most likely reason to me why they jayed trains (like 64/42) between Toronto and Oshawa...
 
You could still buy a ticket for tomorrow, but there are only two possibilities: either VIA got enough LEs qualified for the York and Bala Sub (Bala Sub is usually only worked by Capreol crews) - or they relied on CN pilots. In any case, crewing issues appear to me as the most likely reason to me why they jayed trains (like 64/42) between Toronto and Oshawa...
They are using VIA pilots for the Bala Sub portion. The crews that operate the Corridor trains form a different pool from those that operate the Canadian, and so aren't trained for the tracks up the Don Valley.

They are using CN pilots for the running on the York Sub.

Dan
 
They are using VIA pilots for the Bala Sub portion. The crews that operate the Corridor trains form a different pool from those that operate the Canadian, and so aren't trained for the tracks up the Don Valley.

They are using CN pilots for the running on the York Sub.

Dan
So then the extra crews get off at Oshawa and head back to Union on westbound trains?
 
So then the extra crews get off at Oshawa and head back to Union on westbound trains?
They certainly didn’t travel East of Oshawa.

Apparently, several trains have been cancelled and I assume that’s also due to the lack of pilots and slots on the single-tracked Eastern end of the York (just as for the jaying of the remaining trains)

Travel Advisory: Due to a railway
infrastructure maintenance by the Host Railway on November 27 and 28, 2021, the line will be closed, and trains will run on a different route. Trains 643, 63, 65, 53, 55, 69, 59, 669 will incur significant delays upon arriving in Toronto. There will be no service to or from Guildwood Station on November 27 and 28, 2021. Toronto's Union Station is suggested as the closer alternative.


Here a list of the supposedly cancelled trains:

Cancelled trains

Sat, Nov 27 - 61, 67; 60, 66; 47, 645, 55; 50, 40, 46.
Sun, Nov 28 - 67; 668; 47, 645; 50, 42.


 
They certainly didn’t travel East of Oshawa.

Apparently, several trains have been cancelled and I assume that’s also due to the lack of pilots and slots on the single-tracked Eastern end of the York (just as for the jaying of the remaining trains)

Travel Advisory: Due to a railway
infrastructure maintenance by the Host Railway on November 27 and 28, 2021, the line will be closed, and trains will run on a different route. Trains 643, 63, 65, 53, 55, 69, 59, 669 will incur significant delays upon arriving in Toronto. There will be no service to or from Guildwood Station on November 27 and 28, 2021. Toronto's Union Station is suggested as the closer alternative.


Here a list of the supposedly cancelled trains:

Cancelled trains

Sat, Nov 27 - 61, 67; 60, 66; 47, 645, 55; 50, 40, 46.
Sun, Nov 28 - 67; 668; 47, 645; 50, 42.


I always thought it is short sighted of CN to only build single track bridges instead of making the whole line double tracked.
 

Like so many of these articles, they don’t seem to understand that HFR and HSR serve different markets, and one doesn’t preclude the other. It is kind of like saying we shouldn’t have any highways because we have airports. I’ve said it before, but HFR competes primarily with intercity automotive travel and HSR competes primarily with intercity air travel.
 
If this was simply a question of comparing the benefits, we would have already built HSR decades ago.

The question, however, is whether the incremental benefits of HSR over conventional Medium-Speeds intercity rail service (e.g. 170-230 km/h) is worth the incremental costs.

The only thing interesting about that article was the following graph:

website


As you can see, the capital cost of HFR (based on the figures provided in this article) would translate to $136 million per minute travel time saved, whereas for taking the extra step towards HSR, that metric rises to $227 million (i.e. 67% higher), as HSR supposedly represents 5 times the costs of HFR, but only 3.4 times its travel time savings:

Status QuoHFR (according to 2021 La Presse article)HSR (according to 2021 La Presse article)HSR vs. HFR (according to 2021 La Presse article)
Travel time TRTO-MTRL5:044:002:181:42 faster
Travel time MTRL-QBEC3:243:001:131:47 faster
Travel time TRTO-MTRL-QBEC (combined)8:287:003:313:29 faster
Travel time savedn/a88 minutes297 minutes211 minutes faster
Average speed TRTO-MTRL (485 km Euclidean distance)96 km/h121 km/h211 km/hn/a
Average speed MTRL-QBEC (233 km Euclidean distance)69 km/h78 km/h192 km/hn/a
Average speed TRTO-MTRL-QBEC (718 km Euclidean distance)85 km/h103 km/h204 km/hn/a
Capital costn/a$12 billion$60 billion$48 billion (cost premium)
- per minute savedn/a$136 million$202 million$227 million
 
Last edited:
Thats unfortunate. Could they not terminate trains at Oshawa or terminate half at Oshawa and half over the York Sub to Union?
Surely they can have all VIA trains go to Union Station via Oshawa VIA station. Am I missing something?

A stop at Oriole/Leslie wouldn't hurt either, but understandable that they don't do that quickly.
 
VIADetourDonValley.png

Looks like the construction work on Lakeshore East gives people a new view of the city when going to and from Montreal and Ottawa. I find it crazy that at Hagerman, Doncaster, and Snider you can only head west on the York subdivision when coming from downtown. The only way onto the York subdivision east is via the Halton subdivision which is as far west as you can go and you would be heading northwest to turn east. Was there better network redundancy in the past and then it was sold off or was it always designed to all roads lead to the Toronto Yard?
 
Last edited:
Surely they can have all VIA trains go to Union Station via Oshawa VIA station. Am I missing something?

A stop at Oriole/Leslie wouldn't hurt either, but understandable that they don't do that quickly.
They cannot of the bridge is out of commission, and there was a fatality making the repair take longer.

I wonder what's going to happen to GO trains for Monday and Tuesday?
 

Back
Top