Steve X
Senior Member
The problem with North America is everyone in school just aims to pass courses with just a C or even D. If they beat the average, they are happy. When schools try to set curriculums to higher standards, parents complain their is too much homework and it's too hard. They proclaim As for for Aliens and thus they being this to everyday life and society. This is how York University Station with a huge concrete patch on the wall on opening day passed the test and was deem acceptable.Bringing this here so it's probably more relevant.
All of the standards are nationwide, so all of the cars are sourced from one of two companies, and they all have similar designs and builds. The stations are all designed the same so they have the same requirements on escalators, elevators, platform doors, etc. The one major thing that isn't national standard is the info boards and video boards inside of the cars which indicate next steps and provide safety messaging, and the platform video boards which all vary. For example:
As with anything, I think we don't realize what we do or don't have until we see other systems and how they're doing things. In this regard I think TTC stacks up well against North American (and some European) systems, where the expectation for service seems to be the same. It's not a huge jump to go from TTC to NY, outside of the fact that the NY system is simply much larger, as the stations and trains and everything are fairly similar. It's when you go to Asia, at least from my impression this trip, that the quality and expectation raises substantially, and we really get a chance to see what we're lacking in our public infrastructure. Obviously there are going to be things that we cannot match on, like building large, widescale projects and lines, but on things like wayfinding, information, and general QOL I think we should strive to at least remain somewhat comparable. Last night I climbed the stairs out of King Station and had to slosh around through standing water as the drains on the stairs weren't draining, whereas in China they have staff putting out carpets and mats at station entrances on rainy days so people don't trail water inside...Some Shanghai Metro platforms and trains don't have video boards at all.
View attachment 653151
Shanghai Metro platform video board, times are for next train and third train arriving. Most Chinese Metro headways are 5minutes rush and 7minutes off.
View attachment 653160
Shanghai Metro has a ferry system which traverses the river in a number of places, providing connections mainly for moped drivers who cannot cross on large bridges or tunnels, or for tourists travelling between the Bund and Lujiazui. Because this is included in the Metro system the same charge is applied as a subway or bus (roughly $0.50-0.70, depending on the trip). Including this as it relates to Toronto for no reason whatsoever.
View attachment 653154
Speaking of Lujiazui!
View attachment 653161
I don't think i've ever seen so much greenspace in a "CBD" before. Something that both China and Japan do well, and something that we should definitely do more of, is raised pedestrian bridges to cross busy intersections and avenues. Where's my pedestrian bridge to cross Lakeshore?
View attachment 653162
Hangzhou Metro, station exit info, indicating which car you're in and which stair/escalator you're closest to, and which is ideal for which exit.
View attachment 653164
Hangzhou Metro indicates stations which are not open yet:
View attachment 653153
Wuhan Metro platform video boards, like all others, indicate time for the next train and the train after that.
View attachment 653155
Wuhan Metro in-car board is more busy and difficult to read at first glance.
View attachment 653156
Most metro systems will indicate the level of air conditioning on subway cars. In Harbin, they provide an indication of how busy the cars are and time of arrival for next train, second train, and third train.
View attachment 653157
Pointy trains at Beijing North Station. Don't think we have these.
View attachment 653158
Also checked out the Wuhan hanging monorail, which at this point is just showing off for the sake of showing off.
View attachment 653159
Also, what happened to Barney Beaver? Every metro should have a cute mascot.![]()
In East Asia, everyone aims for As and thus all the designs and plans are reflected in this mentality. How can we expect better when half the class graduating in this society just wing it and do the same in the workplace?




