News   Nov 22, 2024
National Housing Day: City of Toronto and Riverdale Co-op Open Affordable Homes
 332     1 
News   Nov 22, 2024
Bauhaus Condos Rising in Toronto's Old Town
 752     4 
News   Nov 22, 2024
49-Storey Waterfront Tower Proposed at Spadina and Queens Quay
 1.9K     6 

SmartTrack (Proposed)

Bordercollie said:
End of the year....
Click to expand...
I mean, clearly in the quote I referenced, but I was curious if there was anything official.

At any rate, a simple Google search does pull up an article with the end of 2023 timeline:

Ford government promises fare integration between Toronto, surrounding regions by end of 2023 | Globalnews.ca

Associate minister Stan Cho said fare and service integration is "happening this year and will include Toronto," adding the province is "committing to full funding" the program.
globalnews.ca globalnews.ca
 
I'd hope, that like GO Expansion, once the project is done, that we don't call it that anymore. Which would hopefully be true of "Crosstown" as well.
 
nfitz said:
I'd hope, that like GO Expansion, once the project is done, that we don't call it that anymore. Which would hopefully be true of "Crosstown" as well.
Click to expand...
As far as I can tell, they call it "the Smart Track Stations program" and not the "Smart Track Line" or whatever. The Smart Track branding is just a useless holdover to keep some politicians' egos from bruising. These stations will be branded as regular GO stations once they open.

The "Crosstown" is also just branding for the project itself, not the line. Once it opens it will be called Eglinton Line 5.
 
I don't think I've seen this view of Bloor-Lansdowne Station before (via Metrolinx):
BL.jpg


The glass colour and the railing design on the pedestrian bridge looks a bit different from the other renders we've seen, e.g.:
Bloor-Lansdowne.jpg


As usual with Metrolinx, it's unclear whether the new image reflects the latest design or if it's just a sloppy or out of date render.
 
smably said:
I don't think I've seen this view of Bloor-Lansdowne Station before (via Metrolinx):
View attachment 528746

The glass colour and the railing design on the pedestrian bridge looks a bit different from the other renders we've seen, e.g.:
View attachment 528747

As usual with Metrolinx, it's unclear whether the new image reflects the latest design or if it's just a sloppy or out of date render.
Click to expand...

It would be such a miss to have the bike lanes down with the cars instead of up with the sidewalk. I visited Japan earlier this year and they have bike lanes painted or indicated with paving on big wide sidewalks, as opposed to separated from cars with paint and plastic bollards. Cyclists were all very considerate of pedestrians as well. The cyclists were quite adept at navigating around people walking slowly but also didn't expect to travel very fast, unlike the cyclists here (I'm one of them btw!). Hardly anybody wore helmets because it always felt safe. I guess it just gave me a new perspective about what bike lanes should look like -- wider sidewalks shared with pedestrians vs narrow strips on the road shared with cars.

1703095555894.png


This is a great example of why I think the Tokyo approach would be better. With the arrangement seen in this rendering it would be really hard for the cyclists to stop here and get on the train. They'd have travel another 100m or so to the next spot where the road rises back up to become level with the sidewalk again, safely stop, get off their bike and walk it back all that distance on a narrow sidewalk boxed in by a fence. If the bike lane was at sidewalk level, cyclists could just check for pedestrians, slow down and pull over. Right outside the station entrance would be an obvious spot for some bike racks and a BikeShare station.
 
NoahB said:
The Smart Track branding is just a useless holdover to keep some politicians' egos from bruising.
Click to expand...
It is the name of the initiative that led to these stations getting funded and prioritized. It was a strategy to put urban rail / metro into an existing rail corridor plus vacant space along Eglinton West, and evolved into agreements between the city and the province to achieve similar benefits through combined initiatives. Stations the city committed to funding to some degree are called Smart Track stations because they were included in a Smart Track agreement. The combination of the Eglinton West LRT, Smart Track stations, electrification from Bramalea to Union and Union to Unionville, and service improvements expected when this is done will provide a similar service to what Smart Track was trying to achieve.

Will they be GO stations? Sort of... they will be Metrolinx owned stations served by equipment that if it showed up today would have GO branding. Would an EMU running Bramalea-Union-Unionville have GO branding? I have no idea. As Metrolinx builds and owns more of the transit infrastructure irrespective of operator and delivers payment solutions irrespective of operator including fare harmonization initiatives, the terms "GO Stations" and "TTC Stations" become less relevant. For example Mount Dennis is a Metrolinx owned station branded "T" and serviced by UP branded DMUs, GO branded bi-levels, Line 5 barely TTC branded LRTs, and TTC branded local buses... the operators might be Alstom employees, Metrolinx employees, TTC employees, other company employees. I would expect that at some point it will be obvious to everyone that the existing TTC subway infrastructure should be transferred to Metrolinx as well because with the city not funding much of new transit infrastructure any more they are going to own less and less of the stations that exist. The TTC can focus its ownership of infrastructure on bus and streetcar infrastructure (busways, tracks, shelters, garages).

As for Crosstown... I would prefer no line name at all (i.e. only show the roundel and in speaking just call it Line 5), but I would prefer "Crosstown Line" over "Eglinton Line" due to over use of the word "Eglinton" in wayfinding.
 
.
milkycontent said:
It would be such a miss to have the bike lanes down with the cars instead of up with the sidewalk
Click to expand...
Absent significant expensive relating to drains or utilities, one wonders if there is intent to placate bike lane sceptics that “we could just take that space back one day”, like Jarvis
 
Considering the crazy amounts of development happening on Dupont west of Dufferin I wonder if a Smarttrack station on DuPont was ever considered?!
 
Hearing a politician push though a new GO station without any kind of consultation or planning reminded me, whats the status of the Smarttrack stations?

Haven't heard much as of late. Is the city trying to have them kinda under rug swept since Tory's been out and hopefully everyone will just forget about them?
 
robmausser said:
Hearing a politician push though a new GO station without any kind of consultation or planning reminded me, whats the status of the Smarttrack stations?

Haven't heard much as of late. Is the city trying to have them kinda under rug swept since Tory's been out and hopefully everyone will just forget about them?
Click to expand...
There's all sorts of reports and websites about the various SmartTrack stations. Such as https://www.metrolinx.com/en/projec...on/what-were-building/king-liberty-go-station
 
robmausser said:
Right, but what work if any has actually gone on since the last post in here almost a year ago?

The link you posted has been around for a while without any updates on progress.
Click to expand...
There's certainly preliminary work underway at East Harbour. I thought that construction itself was already tendered. The only other one I've passed recently is the worksite at King-Liberty.

If you look at the most recent Capital Projects Commercial Opportunities Pipeline document I think most of the stations are listed there. Bloor-Lansdowne had the RFP close in April. Others seem to have the RFP coming out this year - if they haven't already.

Probably best to check the threads for the stations themselves. Now that construction is underway, and with the 5 stations on 4 different GO lines, then I don't see that there's much need for the overarching thread any more, given it's only about the stations themselves these days, rather than the service. There certainly wasn't more than the stations that will ever happen, if that's what you were looking for.

And of course there's other stations under construction too - and I don't know what difference is between Caledonia station (which isn't SmartTrack) on the Barrie line and Bloor-Lansdowne station on the Barrie line - other than who is paying which part of the bill. (the Caledonia GO station discussion is hidden in the thread for the Caledonia Line 5 station).
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to post here.

Back
Top