Chow has yet to come out with anything that resonates with her base, nor the rest of the populace. She spent way too much time trying to be folksy with the anecdotes and it came across as boring and irrelevant, instead of 'common woman'. I'm not a Chow-hater, but I stick with my prediction that post-Labour Day the anti-Ford vote would pick one of Tory or Chow. It seems they picked Tory. I think this race is over much sooner than we thought possible.
Olivia was more spirited in this debate but her public speaking skills are terrible. I'm not talking about her accent, here, or her lapses in grammar; I'm talking about her style.
In debate, she needs to put Tory on the spot. In her rebuttal, she frequently asked him a hardhitting question. BUT, she didn't stop talking! She kept adding other questions until the moderator and Tory finally broke in. That gave Tory the choice: which of 3 or 4 questions were easiest to answer. Or to lament, as he did more than once, that she had taken gone overtime and he could only give a partial answer.
She has to learn to deliver a message (or a challenge) and stop talking. Instead, she prattles on to fill up her time and it dilutes her message. It also dilutes the effect of her attack on Tory's platitudes. Tory is learning to play her. She lost today because she wasn't focused, didn't get her message out clearly, and didn't know how to use sharp, short sentences or sharp questions. By talking on and on she diminished her credibility and handed the debate to Tory.
I attend Toastmasters and see some grievious but easily conquerable flaws in basic debating skills. Does she not have competent speech advisors? Here was a "fair play" debate without hecklers and she still muffled her own message.
"Fair Play" only in the sense of process. All the questions addressed to her, marginalized her. They were about food programs, how to reduce crime, the arts, etc. Tory questions involved finances, city growth etc. Still, you have to play with the deck you've been given. Olivia has not been properly prepped to engage successfuly in these brinkmanship debates. I blame this on her team. If they smarten up, there is still time to present her as a superior candidate to Tory. I don't see it coming, though.