Urban Shocker
Doyenne
This?
Yes, thanks. For such a small building ( at first glance it's difficult to judge the scale ) it was monumental in effect, and combined historical references ( to Venetian forms, for instance ... ) with sculptural effects - incised horizontals and portholes - to express the spirit of the small and rather obscure congregation that it was built for in a way that strikes me as quite contemporary to expressionist work being done nowadays ( OCADU, the Crystal, Gehry's AGO Dundas facade ) around town. Demolished in 1910, and on my favourites list in this thread:
http://urbantoronto.ca/forum/showthread.php/18306-Top-10-Lost-Toronto-Buildings