I am a new member to UT but I have been reading posts for a very long time and this thread is, by far, my favourite. I started at page one months ago and read all the posts and examined all the pictures carefully. FASCINATING!!!
It's like a time machine. So much is familiar from the old days. Sometimes I am able to look at a picture and feel myself right there where the photographer was standing at the moment the picture was taken. I can hear the traffic on cobblestones between streetcar tracks or smell the air of a fading industrial downtown, or even hear the songbirds in a stand of trees along an old city thoroughfare. It's truly magical.
I absolutely love trying to guess the year of a "Then" photo before peeking at the date (If there is one). I call this detective work:
Forensic Chronology but I'm sure it has a real name. I use period clothing, pricing of products in advertising, buildings that are missing or old ones that are still there and so on. Of course I also date the automobiles in the pics as a guideline. Which brings me to my point:
...Then: Queen S side, just E of Logan. C1978? No cars in the picture to help date this one. Just going by the clothes....
On some posts a forumer has dated a picture practically to the month by the cars in the picture. I feel using the age of cars in a picture, to guess when it was, is a real crap shoot. Especially the the nearer to the present you are.
The likelihood that a brand new (for that model year) car happens into the frame at the moment it was taken, is rather high. People kept cars for a few years longer during the recession of the late fifties for example. This would skew the dating. What if the newest car in the picture was someone's collector car at the time?
In the last couple of decades they are building cars so much better that people can keep them for ten years or more. Which was unheard of in the sixties. This will definitely make it difficult for future "Then and Now" viewers to figure out the "Then" pictures.
All I'm saying is: Car dating is a starting point rather than a definitive answer to the question of "When?"
Meanwhile, my hat is off to all those car lovers that can name and date an obscure model that is far beyond my abilities.
And further, my deepest gratitude to all contributors to this thread and especially to Mustapha for all his hard work. Thank you.