News   Apr 26, 2024
 1.8K     4 
News   Apr 26, 2024
 413     0 
News   Apr 26, 2024
 1K     1 

Finch West Line 6 LRT

Finch will have a CBTC system installed; same implementation as Vancouver Skytrain uses.


I expect the intended use is to eliminate bunching (guarantee vehicles remain X minutes apart) by adjusting vehicle travel speed.

Finch will have a CBTC system, and it will be called SelTrac, but it won't be the same system that Vancouver's Skytrain or Ottawa's Confederation Line (or the SRT, for that matter) uses.

SelTrac is a bit of a catch-all brand name owned by Thales, and they put all of their various signalling systems into it. One of the products under the SelTrac name is a onboard switch and signal activation and routing system, which is basically a highly-evolved version of the "NA" system that is currently used by the legacy streetcars downtown. This is likely what will be used on Finch.

Dan
 
Finch will have a CBTC system installed; same implementation as Vancouver Skytrain uses.


I expect the intended use is to eliminate bunching (guarantee vehicles remain X minutes apart) by adjusting vehicle travel speed.
If the signal system is actually integrated with the traffic lights, that will be great. I feel like it's just a speed control system on the surface stretch. The driver will still drive it like a streetcar.

ML has posted on it's FAQ videos that it takes 38 minutes to travel the whole line. That's 10 whole minutes more than the EA suggesting 28 minutes. That's pretty much the speed the 36 Finch West bus travels at.
 
ML has posted on it's FAQ videos that it takes 38 minutes to travel the whole line. That's 10 whole minutes more than the EA suggesting 28 minutes. That's pretty much the speed the 36 Finch West bus travels at.

Its the great north american safety delusion we are having over on this side of the pond. Speed limits are being reduced, train and lrt speed limits reduced. Pretty soon we will have to drive backwards.
 
Finch will have a CBTC system, and it will be called SelTrac, but it won't be the same system that Vancouver's Skytrain or Ottawa's Confederation Line (or the SRT, for that matter) uses.

SelTrac is a bit of a catch-all brand name owned by Thales, and they put all of their various signalling systems into it. One of the products under the SelTrac name is a onboard switch and signal activation and routing system, which is basically a highly-evolved version of the "NA" system that is currently used by the legacy streetcars downtown. This is likely what will be used on Finch.

Dan

Sorry what does NA stand for?
 
North America

Cute. Actually, it stands for “Necessity Action”. It’s the Model T of remote switch operation technology....press a button on the operator’s console, and the switch throws. Check it out next time you ride a Witt or PCC car.

- Paul
 
Cute. Actually, it stands for “Necessity Action”. It’s the Model T of remote switch operation technology....press a button on the operator’s console, and the switch throws. Check it out next time you ride a Witt or PCC car.

- Paul

It stands for Not Available because the electronic switch controls are broken half the time.
 
38 minutes for the entire line is atrocious. It is almost guaranteed give LRTs a bad name and reduce the already low public support for them.
 
I do not see how 38 minutes is atrocious at all. Literally driving the corridor is 30 right now according to Google Maps, if there was a bad traffic jam it could easily be much more. 38 minutes reliably on this route is fine.

If the velocity isn’t better than driving, why would people choose not to drive?

- Paul
 
Finch will have a CBTC system installed; same implementation as Vancouver Skytrain uses.


I expect the intended use is to eliminate bunching (guarantee vehicles remain X minutes apart) by adjusting vehicle travel speed.
So does that mean the line is automated? Or is it another form of the SelTrac system in which it isn't automated?
 
If the velocity isn’t better than driving, why would people choose not to drive?

- Paul

You can slash your expenses considerably if you're paying for parking at work, paying higher insurance rates for a longer-distance commute, and wearing out and depreciating your car by commuting. In addition to the financial incentives, you can read or do work during your commute by transit.
 

Back
Top