News   Nov 05, 2024
 402     1 
News   Nov 05, 2024
 1.5K     2 
News   Nov 05, 2024
 570     0 

Baby, we got a bubble!?

From the Star:

RE: 10 York:


Looking up
Published on Friday November 16, 2012
Share on twitter Share on facebook
SUPPLIED ILLUSTRATION The base of the building will feature a glass-enclosed lobby with 30-foot-high ceilings in a triangular shape, to match the sit on which it will sit.
3 of 3
Ryan Starr
Special to the Star

Anyone pondering the current state of Toronto’s condo market may want to take note of the rip-roaring success of Tridel’s recently launched Ten York project.

The 65-storey glass tower — which will rise from a wedge-shaped site at York and Harbour Sts. — has been regarded as a bellwether, a development whose sales performance this fall would offer an indication of the health of a condo market that some analysts believe has become oversupplied.

Of the 600 units at Ten York released to date, 532 had been sold as of early November.
If the Toronto condo market is cooling, “you sure as heck wouldn’t have known that from what was happening at our sales office,” notes Jim Ritchie, Tridel’s senior vice president of sales and marketing.

In all, Ten York will have 694 residences, ranging from 564-square-foot one-bedroom units to 3,858-square-foot three-bedroom suites. Prices start at $345,000. Occupancy of the project is slated for summer 2017.

Tridel is developing Ten York in partnership with Build Toronto, an independent and self-funding real estate and development corporation with a mandate to maximize the value of under-utilized real estate previously owned by the city.

The development is the first joint residential project on which Build Toronto has partnered with a private builder.

Suites at Ten York — designed by II BY IV Design Associates — will have nine-foot ceilings and engineered-laminate plank flooring.

Kitchens will have granite or quartz countertops and AEG stainless steel appliances. Bathrooms come with white quartz countertops and five-foot soaker tubs.

Suites include a stacked Energy Star front-loading washer and dryer, and will have individual metering of electricity, hot water and heating/cooling.

Ten York’s amenities include a gym and studios for spinning, yoga and cardio; and an outdoor pool, spa and saunas. The building also will have a billiards room, media/games room, theatre room, party room and private dining room, as well as guest suites and a concierge.

Battling ‘doom and gloom’

In spite of Ten York’s impressive sales, headlines proclaiming a condo market downturn have created quite a few headaches for Ritchie and his team. “Our biggest challenge is consumer confidence,” he says.

“People read headlines and they don’t really understand what’s going on, so they just see it as doom and gloom. The more this stuff is written about, the harder it is to convince somebody they should be buying a condo.”

Ritchie acknowledges “we’ve had challenges in the marketplace over the past few months,” however, he suggests that Ten York’s location and design have had a lot to do with the project’s success.

“We did a tremendous amount of market research and testing our prospect database (which included more than 5,000 registrants), and it told us that in spite of what you might read in the papers, there were buyers for this in the community.

“Tall buildings in the downtown core with water views are in demand, and I think we’ve proven that.”

Design changes

Ten York generated big buzz last fall when preliminary plans for the project were unveiled.

The tower design has since undergone a number of significant changes in response to feedback from the city.

Most significantly, Ten York’s height has been reduced to 65 storeys from the originally proposed 75 storeys.

The look of the building has been tweaked, as well, becoming more triangular in form to correspond better with the wedge-shaped site on which it will sit, located between the Gardiner Expressway and the York St. off-ramp at the northwest corner of Harbour and York Sts.

“(Changing the design of the tower) allowed us also to push the building, including the base, further to the west, which will create wider pedestrian access along York St.,” notes Ritchie.

The tower redesign also saw the parking garage, originally proposed to be above-grade, moved underground, freeing up space in the podium. The base of the building will now feature a glass-enclosed lobby with 30-foot-high ceilings.

“We’ve created a pretty spectacular lobby space,” says Ten York’s architect Rudy Wallman. “Because it’s so high and transparent, it will act as an extension of the sidewalk.”

Despite the tower being knocked down from 75 storeys to 65, changes to the form of the building resulted in a negligible reduction in the number of suites, from 774 to 694.

The new building design also minimizes the use of balconies. West-facing suites will have them, as will units on the northeast and southeast corners of the tower, but the north and south facades will be glass curtain walls.

“I think that’s a huge bonus visually,” Wallman says. “We don’t have to deal with inset or projecting balconies, which really give residential buildings the look they have, which tends to be cluttered if not handled well.

“Here it’s going to be very sleek and finished looking; more like a commercial building.”

Still an icon

Ten York is no longer in the running to become one of Toronto’s tallest residential towers, but Ritchie maintains the 224-metre building will be iconic all the same.

“When you look at some of the renderings we created — we went out over the lake with a helicopter with a steady cam and shot the core of the city, and then had the building rendered into it so we could see what the overall effect is — I think it looks pretty darn good at 65 floors.”

“It won’t make us the tallest, but we’re right up there,” he adds. “And besides, it was never the race to be the tallest. We wanted the right solution

Details

Location: 10 York St.

Developers: Tridel, tridel.com, and Build Toronto, buildtoronto.ca

Architect: Wallman Architects

Interiors: II BY IV Design Associates, iibyiv.com

Size: 65 storeys

Units: 694, one-bedroom to three-bedroom.

Prices: From $345,000

Amenities: Gym, pool, party room, theatre, guest suites

Information:tridel.com, 416-596-9888, tenyork@tridel.com



This seems to confirm my earlier view that a few high profile projects such as this will still sell. I expect smaller buildings will do so as well. The problem will be the "standard 20-40 storey buildings in downtown with little to distinguish them as Marquis projects.

A few numbers:
532 of 600 is 89%. Of the total units: 532/694=77%. I presume they released all but the "executive higher floors and larger suites and these may prove to be a bit more difficult to sell.
Selling price starting: $345K/564 or $612/sq.ft.

 
Why does anyone want to buy a condo between the Gardiner Expressway and an exit ramp from the Gardiner Expressway? The noise, pollution and car accidents on the highway would be a huge problem there.
 
Why does anyone want to buy a condo between the Gardiner Expressway and an exit ramp from the Gardiner Expressway? The noise, pollution and car accidents on the highway would be a huge problem there.

That's a very good question. I wonder about that also. As soon as you step out of the building, you're faced with traffic lights on both north and south side. There's hardly any breathing room on that small foot print. I suspect most buyers haven't actually seen the exact location and only saw the model where they eliminate most of the surroundings. The building has been highly advertised as well. I hear it on the Chinese radio and it runs around 10 times or so during the day, every day.
 
Last edited:
That's a very good question. I wonder about that also. As soon as you step out of the building, you're faced with traffic lights on both north and south side. There's hardly any breathing room on that small foot print. I suspect most buyers haven't actually seen the exact location and only saw the model where they eliminate most of the surroundings. The building has been highly advertised as well. I hear it on the Chinese radio and it runs around 10 times or so during the day, every day.

1 simple answer. Investors, not end users. If you are high enough up, I don't think the expressways are an issue. Yes, a wedge to get in but for most people that is not all that relevant I would think. It is the location if you like MLS and ICE, then why not this one?
 
1 simple answer. Investors, not end users. If you are high enough up, I don't think the expressways are an issue. Yes, a wedge to get in but for most people that is not all that relevant I would think. It is the location if you like MLS and ICE, then why not this one?

personally, as an end-user i would not like any of these projects for the location nor the expected number of investor/rental units, which most likely is 50% at least.
 
1 simple answer. Investors, not end users. If you are high enough up, I don't think the expressways are an issue. Yes, a wedge to get in but for most people that is not all that relevant I would think. It is the location if you like MLS and ICE, then why not this one?

Well, MLS and ICE location has a better edge than 10 York. MLS entrances have less traffic. Sometimes part of the area is even closed off to traffic. If you look at the streets, it's been redone with maple leaf design so it looks like the pedestrian sidewalks. Ice doesn't have that, but it has underground PATH to MLS. So you don't need to face the traffic. You don't even need to walk out in the winter because there's a PATH to Union station. If you want the energy of the street during a game or concert, you can walk outside. The stripe a long bremner is pretty busy. 10 York is divided into a corner like a lost child. I get the same feeling for 10 York as I do for Panorama.
 
I've been in that area, and to be fair, it's steps away from Harbourfront. With Queen's Quay improvements that are coming, and the simcoe offramp to be removed, there are worse out-the-door atmosphere. I almost bought one there.


If I did, probly one of the very few end-users.
 
Midmonth November #s are a price increase of 1.7% YOY. With a 2% inflation rate, that's the first YoY price decrease we've seen in a while, albeit just half a month's data.
http://www.torontorealestateboard.c...market_updates/news2012/nr_mid_month_1112.htm

1.7% YOY is a significant drop from October's 6.2% YOY (a drop of about $15K overall). I think we're just starting to see some of the more pricier properties getting pinched in price. Full November numbers will tell a better tale...
 
Last edited:
RBT, I was just shooting from the hip on that reference to "2% inflation". I don't follow the monthly movements. Apologies for any confusion
DT
 
Midmonth November #s are a price increase of 1.7% YOY. With a 2% inflation rate, that's the first YoY price decrease we've seen in a while, albeit just half a month's data.
http://www.torontorealestateboard.c...market_updates/news2012/nr_mid_month_1112.htm

Furthermore;

Average price in the 416, $522,852 - down 0.3 % Y/Y. Sales down 23% Y/Y

Condo prices in the 416, $347,681 - down 3.8% Y/Y. Sales down 21.7% Y/Y

Sales of detached houses in the 416 down 26.6% Y/Y.


Ouch.
 
Last edited:
Those are year to year comparison and last year was a record breaking year.
If you compare this year to 2010 figures it wouldn't be so shocking.

Also shrinking condo sizes is to blame for the falling condo prices.
 
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/housing/flahertys-rule-changes-will-bite-hard-mortgage-brokers/article5410889/


"The CAAMP report suggests that more than 16 per cent of the high-ratio borrowers (that is, those with a down payment of less than 20 per cent) who obtained a mortgage in 2010 would no longer qualify if they had sought that same mortgage under today’s rules.

A survey conducted for CAAMP suggests that 55 per cent of home sales are financed with a high-ratio mortgage."

Can these numbers be correct?
 
Last edited:
Those are year to year comparison and last year was a record breaking year.
If you compare this year to 2010 figures it wouldn't be so shocking.

Also shrinking condo sizes is to blame for the falling condo prices.

Neuhaus, 2011 Nov sales were only slightly above the average of recent years, and were lower than 2007 and 2009. Also, these stats are for resale condo sales, not new condos - so the shrinking size is not an issue YoY.
http://guava.ca/indicators.html
 

Back
Top