News   Aug 01, 2024
 688     0 
News   Aug 01, 2024
 778     0 
News   Aug 01, 2024
 560     0 

Urban Shocker's Neighbourhood Watch

Carmen-Canadian Opera Company

I saw this yesterday. It sort of lay on the stage, occasionally twitching to life, then falling back down. Where was the passion? I loved Bryan Hymel as Don Jose, Jessica Muirhead as Micaela, the Gypsy girls, and the opera chorus. Rinat Shaham looks the part of Carmen and that was about it. Paul Grey as Escamillo sang a limp rendition of "Toreador". This production needs the operatic equivalent of Viagra.
 
... This production needs the operatic equivalent of Viagra.

LMAO! This production just can't "keep it up" by all reviews. Well, we're going Tuesday, just can't wait!

...I think I'll have to content myself with the singing in the main roles, and take what I can get from that.

Thanks!
 
The Globe on Carmen:

Published on Thursday, Jan. 28, 2010 3:23PM EST
By Ken Winters

" The Canadian Opera Company greeted the new year Wednesday with a revival of its 2005 production of Bizet's Carmen, which was fortunate indeed to be redeemed by a believable trio of lead singers.

Israeli mezzo-soprano Rinat Shaham was a stunning Carmen Рto see, to hear, to experience dramatically. New Orleans tenor Bryan Hymel turned in a passionate and thrillingly sung Don Jos̩. Canadian soprano Jessica Muirhead was a persuasive and touching Micaela. The three, beautifully abetted by the COC orchestra under Scottish conductor Rory Macdonald and the COC chorus trained by Sandra Horst, provided a stirring central musico-dramatic core, which sustained us through this astonishing, beautiful and still-upsetting work.

My vote goes also to whoever made the astute decision to restore the connective dialogue between scenes to its original spoken form. After Bizet’s death, in a stupid attempt to subvert his revolutionary upending of the opéra-comique format to accommodate a new, brisker opéra-tragique, the obliging but modestly gifted Ernest Guiraud was engaged to make an adaptation of those spoken words into time-consuming sung and accompanied recitative.

The object of this impertinence was to turn Bizet’s work into a proper “grand opera.” All it achieved was a dulling of its point and a blurring of the clear outlines of Bizet’s perfectly judged and exquisitely proportioned scenes. So, congratulations go to whoever decided to eliminate Guiraud’s contribution from this COC revival.

U.S. designer Michael Yeargan’s sets are the least appealing reminder of the 2005 production. Yeargan’s Act I is satisfactory, if uninspired, with its high, wrought-iron fence and gates. His Act II tavern has a tacky fifties look, with turquoise plastic chairs, corroborated by designer François St-Aubin’s entrance costume for the bullfighter Escamillo, which looks like a snappy casual outfit from an old L.L. Bean fall catalogue. Yeargan’s Act III, the “smugglers’ camp,” made you wonder if he’d ever seen a smuggler or a camp. And his Act IV set was hardest of all to enjoy, with its sterile under-the-stairs-at-the-stadium look. Couldn’t we have had some seething dust and merciless Spanish sun for Carmen’s bloody murder?

Director Justin Way’s restaging of this revival improved some scenes, not others. The smugglers’ encampment eluded him as it had eluded the designer.

But the singing and Bizet’s music saved the day. The only one of the principals to disappoint was the complacent but stolid French bass-baritone Paul Gay. His Escamillo didn’t look much like any toreador I ever saw and the bass end of his bass-baritone didn’t have the required low notes, nor had the baritone end of it the rolling, ringing virility it needs.

The smaller roles were mostly very well filled. Quebec bass Alain Coulombe was a rock-solid Captain of the Guard. Baritone Alexander Hajek had an excellent opening scene, vocally assured and convincing. Soprano Teiya Kasahara and mezzo-soprano Lauren Segal were splendid as Carmen’s companions Frasquita and Mercedes, as were baritone Justin Welsh and tenor Adam Luther, representing two resourceful smugglers.

For me, though, the essence of Bizet’s Carmen came through most indelibly in Shaham’s singing and personification of Carmen’s famous arias, especially her sombre and tragic Card Scene; and in Hymel’s gripping portrayal of a doomed Don José, evident throughout, from his ecstatic Flower Song in Act II to the shocking dénouement of Act IV – all of it believable, all of it sung. "
 
The Post on Carmen:

Arthur Kaptainis, National Post
Published: Friday, January 29, 2010

Carmen - It's the colour that counts

" Probably the most popular opera in the world, Bizet's Carmen is also the most frequently updated. On Wednesday, the Canadian Opera Company revived its 2005 production, co-authored with the Opera de Montreal and San Diego Opera, which pushes the action up to the 1950s and transports it from Spain to an ill-lit Latin republic.

You want to know why? Console yourself instead with the knowledge that the resulting incongruities are mild by current international standards, and that the costumes (including scarlet shirts for the soldiers) at least pay homage to the colour that used to be synonymous with this masterpiece. The British director Justin Way, making his COC debut, also brought a relatively traditional sensibility to the Four Seasons Centre stage. Goodness, Escamillo stood on a table during the Toreador Song.

But the core demonstration of traditional operatic values came from Rinat Shaham, the firm-toned Israeli mezzo-soprano in the title role. Yes, she planted her hands on her hips, but most fetchingly, and both her vocal and bodily acting suggested a complex character racked by uncertainties rather than a generically independent gypsy.

Bryan Hymel, an American tenor, was more into heavy metal projection than finesse, but his portrayal of Don Jose as an unlucky doofus could hardly fail to register with those gentlemen in the audience who have themselves pursued self-destructive obsessions.

Jessica Muirhead, a Canadian soprano enjoying much success in Europe, followed the current trend toward determined rather than compliant interpretations of Micaela, the country girl whose messages from home torment Don Jose almost as much as Carmen's sultry glances. Her aria, fresh and clarion, was a highlight. French bass-baritone Paul Gay sang crisply but cut a rather suburban figure as Escamillo.

Conductor Rory Macdonald, another British newcomer, elicited lively but not overheated sounds from the COC Orchestra, which did nothing to diminish its sterling reputation, and the choristers (including kids) sang with such zest in the final act that you almost forgave the absence of the brilliant parade they describe. Almost.

Here is an original idea for the next COC Carmen: Seville in the 1830s. The concept works remarkably well, with the libretto and the music. Is the company bold enough to give it a try? "
 
And here's an interview with Yannick Nezet-Seguin, from the February edition of Wholenote magazine:

( unfortunately, neither the link nor the printout from that link that I've provided contain the last part of the interview, which is available in the print copy of the magazine )

http://thewholenote.com/

Written by Allan Pulker

" One of Toronto’s favourite musicians is a Montrealer: conductor and pianist Yannick Nézet-Séguin. And it’s been fascinating to watch the rise of this gifted artist, from Toronto’s vantage point.

In 2003, Quebec conductor Bernard Labadie suggested that Toronto’s Bach Consort invite Nézet-Séguin to conduct Bach’s Christmas Oratorio. (According to Toronto Symphony Orchestra bass player, Tim Dawson, who carries much of the responsibility for the Bach Consort, Labadie said, “Yannick is really very good, you know.â€) In October 2004, he stepped in to conduct the Toronto Symphony at the last minute, replacing an ailing Emmanuel Krivine in an all-Russian programme, which included Shostakovich’s Fifth Symphony. This performance, as I recall, was received with unanimous critical acclaim. In March 2005 he returned to the TSO as guest conductor. Of those performances one reviewer wrote: “soloist and orchestra maintained a sensitive balance and the music came through as an integrated whole. Nézet-Séguin deserves the lion’s share of credit.†He has been back in Toronto every year since then as guest conductor; and in 2007, in the midst of conducting Gounod’s Faust for the Canadian Opera Company, was whisked from the Four Seasons Centre to Roy Thomson Hall, to lead the TSO, replacing Valery Gergiev.

In January of that year I interviewed him during a break in rehearsals for Faust. The big news in that interview, which became the cover story of The WholeNote’s February 2007 issue, was the very recent announcement that he’d been appointed principal conductor of the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra. While in Toronto that month he was conducting not only the COC but also the Bach Consort, as well as performing Schubert’s Die Winterreise in recital as a pianist with baritone Alexander Dobson.

There are two big news items this time: first, Nézet-Séguin will be back in Toronto on February 24, this time not as a guest conductor but as the conductor of his own orchestra, the Rotterdam Philharmonic; and second, the first recording of the Rotterdam Philharmonic conducted by Nézet-Séguin has recently been released by EMI classics. According to publicity materials, the disc “explores Ravel’s orchestral music through three themes: childhood, Ancient Greece and waltzes,†and presents Ravel as, in Nézet-Séguin’s words, “the greatest orchestrator French music has ever had.â€

In mid January I spoke with a very busy Yannick Nézet-Séguin on the phone. He had just returned to New York from Montreal (where he had conducted a concert by l’Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montéal) to conduct that evening another performance of Bizet’s Carmen at the Metropolitan Opera, a run which has been receiving rave reviews. It’s clear that he’s popular all over the place, not just in Toronto. Indeed, something I haven’t even mentioned is that he is principal guest conductor of the London Philharmonic Orchestra, which he will conduct four more times this season: February 10, 13, 14 and April 10.

This young Canadian is obviously doing something right, very right, to have rocketed to the upper echelons of the conducting world in such a short time. Nine years ago he was the music director of a regional orchestra in Montreal, now he is in charge of one of the world’s great orchestras, and is welcomed with open arms as the guest conductor of the best orchestras everywhere. I wanted to find out in my conversation with him how he was able to draw such a positive response from orchestras, audiences and critics wherever he goes.

I asked him to speak about his approach to three areas of a conductor’s work: preparation (getting to know the scores to be conducted), rehearsal and performance.

He began by pointing out that there is a big difference between learning a score for the first time and preparing to conduct a score that he’s already conducted. “A few years ago everything I did was for the first time, but now I have a repertoire.†He is curious by nature, however, and has to be careful not to overload himself with new music to learn: “I like to discover things, but it’s also such an enormous amount of work to learn anything for the first time,†even if it’s something he’s been listening to since he was 12. His golden rule in preparation is never to let it show that it’s the first time, to learn it so well that everyone just assumes he’s done it before.

I asked him about his studying process. “It’s very much in a linear way. I go through a score from start to finish, trying first to get a sense of the dramatic or narrative line.†At the same time he also tries to bring into focus the structure, or the architecture of the composition. “I work from the details to the general. I know it’s a relatively unusual approach, but it’s always been my way.â€

I also asked if he uses the piano or if he reads a score like a book. “It can be anywhere – at home or on a plane – but almost never with the piano.†Interestingly, one of Tim Dawson’s comments was: “When visiting Yannick backstage during rehearsal breaks you will invariably find him sitting quietly with the score. He is very friendly with his visitors, but his main focus is always the music. He is busy preparing music for so many programmes that he is constantly studying. He seems to absorb the music very quickly and his memory is phenomenal.â€

And what about recordings as part of his preparation? “Recordings,†he replied, “are important as a preparation before starting to study.†Indeed, he likes to listen to as many different recorded versions of a work as he can get his hands on. Once he has begun to study a score however, he finds recordings almost a frustration. Sometimes he will even feel that a recording he has admired for many years is all wrong, once he’s studied the score.

Moving on to his approach to rehearsals, Yannick’s first comment was that he values rehearsals very much, and doesn’t consider them boring or simply something you have to go through in order to have a concert, where “all the excitement and energy should happen.†In fact, trying to confine all the emotional involvement and magic to the concert can make them a distraction, resulting in performance that is not very deep. “A rehearsal is rewarding when there is something happening – and there’s a good atmosphere and a good pace, sometimes even more rewarding than a good concert.â€

We talked about the atmosphere of the rehearsal. “The right atmosphere has to do with a lot of respect [for the musicians in the orchestra] and focus, but at the same time to be able to have a balance between funny moments and lots of cncentration.†It is also essential to him for the orchestra to relax and begin to breathe together, which allows the music to unfold naturally. He also likes to keep the pace very high and avoid dull moments. And he finds it impossible to work from a rehearsal plan: “
 
^ Urban Shocker, you have missed an article about young Yannick, by Lebrecht. How could you?

Alas, Yannick is apparently not to be ours, but please, do dry your eyes my dear.

Just add Yannick's name to the long and growing list of "the ones that got away" from the TSO's grasp. On that list already, you'll find Stokowski (honestly!), Tennestedt, Jansons (he almost said "yes", but we got Yukka-Pekka instead), Nezet-Sequin (well, I don't know if they ever actually tried) ...

My own personal favourite of all recent guest conductors, who was allegedly shortlisted last time around, was Noseda. He's just too awesome. He's pretty busy now, conducting in St. Petersburg, Milan, Vienna, where else, oh, just name it. He had the TSO scheduled in for November 2010, but the new TSO brochure has someone else conducting in the timeslot in question ... I wonder what happened! Oh, well, we'll have Noseda in February for the Verdi Requiem. Don't miss it. It may be our last chance to hear him around here .... my cat's veterinarian still can't believe the TSO let Noseda get away, he's still pissed about that !!!
 
Last edited:
Regardless of who helms our symphony orchestra, it's nice to know that our early-adopter status as a creative centre keeps us ahead of London and New York and other European capitals as a welcoming venue for rising talent such as Yannick. They're just "getting" him while we've enjoyed him for years.
 
I'm to Otello on Saturday night.

The plot turns on a handkerchief. And, rest assured, a hankie will figure prominently in my splendid outfit ... though it may not be the strawberry-embroidered hankie of the libretto.

IAGO
Nay, but be wise: yet we see nothing done;
She may be honest yet. Tell me but this,
Have you not sometimes seen a handkerchief
Spotted with strawberries in your wife's hand?


OTHELLO
I gave her such a one; 'twas my first gift.

IAGO
I know not that; but such a handkerchief—
I am sure it was your wife's—did I today
See Cassio wipe his beard with.


OTHELLO
If it be that—

IAGO
If it be that, or any that was hers,
It speaks against her with the other proofs.


OTHELLO
O, that the slave had forty thousand lives!
One is too poor, too weak for my revenge.
Now do I see 'tis true. Look here, Iago;
All my fond love thus do I blow to heaven.
'Tis gone.
Arise, black vengeance, from thy hollow cell!
Yield up, O love, thy crown and hearted throne
To tyrannous hate! Swell, bosom, with thy fraught,
For 'tis of aspics' tongues!
 
^ Verdi's adaptation of the Shakespeare work is fascinating and to this point I've only seen it on film (Domingo) -- it's a gripping stage drama, and I hope the COC does it proud. We will see Otello on the 16th.

Re. Carmen, last night, everyone else has said it all. Rinat Shaham is a great Carmen with all the tools required for the role. For me the best moments came from listening to Bryan Hymel. In summary, there were more than a few times that I decided I should just listen with my eyes closed. I liked the conductor, Rory Macdonald, too. I hope he gets the chance to do more work here in Toronto.
 
Right now, I guess I am thinking of Italy. It just occurred to me that in two weeks' time, I'll be seeing / hearing two Verdi masterpieces during the same week:

(COC) Verdi's Otello, conducted by Paolo Olmi, on the 16th, and
(TSO) Verdi's Requiem, conducted by Gianandrea Noseda, on the 20th.

Two great Italian conductors, covering Verdi masterpieces.
 
Have fun.

Anyone going to Gergiev and the Mariinsky Orchestra at RTH in March? I haven't booked. Are there even any good tickets left? There's so much going on these days.
 
Have fun.

Anyone going to Gergiev and the Mariinsky Orchestra at RTH in March? I haven't booked. Are there even any good tickets left? There's so much going on these days.

There is a lot going on these days. I will probably pass on the Mariinsky orchestra this time, having seen (or, heard) them twice before. The second show with the Shostakovich 15th is mildly tempting, though.

I have heard that Gergiev does mean Mahler. If they had programmed that sort of stuff I would buy a ticket. As it is, with more Russian chestnuts (Tchaikovsky's 5th?) I don't feel very tempted.

Other great orchestras tour frequently, but for some reason, Toronto gets passed by. The Berlin Phil, for example, hit the States last autumn, and I would have loved to hear them in Toronto. Maybe on their next tour they'll touch down here.
 
I saw Otello last night. It had everything Carmen lacked. Excellent stuff. Wait until you hear those big, boisterous voices from the leads. Wow.

Interestingly, it got less people on their feet than Carmen did... I can't really understand that.
 

Back
Top