Who ends up paying for this? The developer or the condo owners
While the pedestrian sidewalk around any property (large development like EmeraldPark) is on City-Right-Of-Way Property, it's the developer's (Bazis/Metropia/PlazaCorp hiding behind EmeraldPark 2010 Inc) responsibility to build new sidewalk and whatever public realm entities as agreed upon. And these contracts specifies a certain level of quality.
EmeraldPark buyers already paid for this, along with a certain amount to cover reasonable repairs & re-dos.
Here, the quality of the pedestrian sidewalk and public realm space was so poorly built, at least half had already had to be replaced at the City's request due to poor quality work. I documented this in a previous post about a year after Emerald Park open. Walk around Emerald Park and you'll see so many of the panels of the pedestrian sidewalk are different shades due to re-dos.
Usually, developer smart enough to contractually insist that Contractor are responsible for poor quality work.
The problem with these low-est price contractors is they have stronger financial incentive to do cheapest quality crap work and once there's too much warrantee-repair/redo type of work, they'll just dissolve and declare bankruptcy,... only to reappear under a different company name the next day!
While technically developer is responsible,... I wouldn't be surprise if the developer has a way of shafting these fees back to Emerald Park buyers via maintenance fees.
Building pedestrian sidewalk isn't rocket science. Keep in mind these are sidewalk redo's because the City determine the quality wasn't there (sidewalk cracking prematurely or concrete not durable enough due to adding too much sand filler into mix (cheapening)),... and City insisting these redos must be done to correct the quality issues in the Public Realm space. Now who looks for construction quality issues inside EmeraldPark,... are they ever fixed???? These poor quality build issues will come back!
Once again,... look across the street at Tridel HullmarkCentre,... Tridel build with their own internal worker to ensure high quality work! Examine all the pedestrian sidewalk around Tridel HullmarkCentre for different shade indicating re-do work,.... the only time I ever recall any of their sidewalk panels being redone are a few panels in front of 2 Anndale by the curb about a year ago,... as seen in photo, likely for subway-water vent/fire hydrant work (thus, not due to quality issue but repairing or adding something underneath - maybe water vent for that large flower bed planter).
The way to ensure good quality work for all public realm sidewalk around every development is to force developer to hire the City's approved contractor for such work - any City approved contractor that does poor quality work will no longer be a City approved contractor.