News   Jan 08, 2025
 611     0 
News   Jan 08, 2025
 1K     1 
News   Jan 08, 2025
 539     1 

Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtable)

W

wyliepoon

Guest
Canadian Architect

Link to article

International Architectural Roundtable: TALL TOWERS: Are they a Necessary Evil for the Evolution and Growth of a City?
11/10/2006



This is the opening session for Construct Canada 2006, taking place from November 29-December 1, 2006 at the Metro Toronto Convention Centre. The media sponsor for the roundtable is Canadian Architect magazine, and it takes place from 8:00am to 10:00am on Wednesday, November 29.

Please note that admission to the International Architectural Roundtable is free, and that you will earn three (3) OAA-directed points for attending.

The roundtable represents an exceptional opportunity to hear four highly accomplished and award-winning international architects discuss their perspectives on a major trend facing city building and urban design: the impact of tall buildings on the modern urban form of a major city.

James K.M. Cheng (Vancouver) was born in Hong Kong and received his Master of Architecture from the Graduate School of Design at Harvard University. He studied under Richard Meier, and apprenticed with Arthur Erickson in Canada prior to opening his practice, James KM Cheng Architects. Since its inception, the firm's work has focused on high-density urban projects with the integration of landscape, interior design and architecture. The award-winning firm has constructed over 45 towers and is currently involved in projects in Canada, USA and China.

Tarek El-Khatib (Toronto) of Zeidler Partnership Architects is emerging as one of Canada's leading international architects, undertaking design commissions in Asia, Europe, the Middle East and the Caribbean as well as creating award-winning designs in Canada and the United States. He is responsible for the design of some of the firm's most celebrated buildings. He brings to the design and management of projects a broad knowledge base of building types that has evolved over 23 years of professional experience.

Eugene Kohn (New York) serves as Partner-in-Charge of many of Kohn Pederson Fox's major domestic and international projects. KPF is renowned for buildings that are sensitive to their context, while establishing a unique and memorable image on the exterior and creating interior environments that reinforce the clients' overall mission and function. As a firm with numerous awards and high recognition, they have designed some of the tallest and most notable buildings in the world.

Ken Yeang (London, UK), a director of Llewelyn Davies Yeang, is also a prolific Malaysian architect and writer widely known for the "bioclimatic" design of skyscrapers. Seeing skyscrapers as inevitable because of population pressures and site ratios, Yeang has spent his career refuting the conventional wisdom that tall buildings are inherently destructive to the environment. He has won numerous awards for his bioclimatic techniques and daring "vertical landscaping" in tall buildings around the world.

Moderator for the event is Lisa Rochon, architecture columnist for The Globe and Mail.

Please visit the Construct Canada website for more information on the International Architectural Roundtable.
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

I suppose it's debatable whether they are necessary or not, but why is it taken for granted that highrises are an evil?
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

I agree. What does "evil" have to do with tall buildings? Those mountains that are the backdrop for Vancouver are tall... does it make them evil?
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

You have to wonder about all this anti-tall building stuff. This weekend's Star has a story about brothels in high rise condos, and Adam Vaughan going on about high rise condos as being "vertical sprawl and the product of poor planning.

Is it fashionable to hate tall buildings?
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

The Vaughn article didn't take issue with all high-rises, Vaughn says he supports them. Its the ones that are "vertical sprawl and the product of poor planning" that he has problems with.

But thanks for pointing that out, Boiler. Guess what... not everyone want to live in a townhouse, either! There is still a general dislike of condos that persists among a large segment of the population... I still write it off as a belief that Toronto is something that it hasn't been for many, many years.
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

By vertical sprawl that means what exactly?
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

St. James Town, Cityplace, "Hong Kong-style development", etc...
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

^ But the term doesn't make sense - "sprawl" implies horizontal spread.
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

Well, essentially sprawl is any sort of spread.


I would call many of those slabs vertical slums, in any case; sprawl in itself seems relatively benign.
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

That makes no sense... not being against "high-rises" but being against "vertical sprawl". Vertical sprawl would mean either "higher buildings" or "new high-rise buildings" wouldn't it? The term "sprawl" doesn't have anything to do with quality.
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

Although illogical, it's clear that suburban sprawl means miles of low density and vertical sprawl was coined to characterize towers that are more than 20 feet apart with nothing (podium or other) to connect them to each other or the street.

Ye ole "towers in the park" is a much better interpretation.
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

I'm thinking the criticism from Vaughan and his ilk is more concerned with the *types* of people moving into those condos (homeowner, thus potentially conservative) than on the built form. I reckon new condo dwellers are seen as interlopers in what were formerly happy-dippy-hippy neighbourhoods. (i.e. sprawl=suburban, thus vertical sprawl=suburbia-on-Queen, etc.).
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

Fiendish, I have to say that I enjoy your posts because your ranting ability is second to none! But aren't Vaughn's happy-dippy-hippy scandel wearing rich elitist commie capitalist dog homeowner panhandler ilk not people too?

Seeing as I annually attend the Construct Canada / Property Management / Green building Conference and exhibition I might check this out.
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

Couldn't resist putting this here as well.

tall.jpg
 
Re: Tall Towers: A Necessary Evil?(Construct Canada roundtab

...

:rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin

...
:rollin :rollin :rollin



...
:rollin


...
:p

...

;)

...

:\

...

:(
 

Back
Top