old boy
Senior Member
Stop using " world class " and Toronto in the same sentence. Not that TO isn't, or anything. JUST don't do it !
...
And better an egghead than a Sunday Painter Urbanist amateur like you. Sorry.
An isolated Island ? We would still be part of Canada. I would invite the surrounding municipalities of Durham, York, Peel, Halton & Hamilton to join. Last time I saw figures 25% or so of annual immigrants to Canada settled in within the GTA good luck luring.
As for goodwill & provincial spirit LOL the GTA is under represented compared to the rural population in both Queen's Park & Parliament Hill & more taxes leave the GTA than ever comeback in terms of services. The Greater Toronto Area's population of 5.3m+ (larger than 6 Provinces & 3 Territories) with a labor force of 3.1m. The GTA's GDP totals approximately $264B, or about half of Ontario's, the same as Quebec & larger than every other Province & Territory in Canada.
A GTA with Provincial Powers would be able to have it's own Lotteries, Casinos, LCBO, Income Tax, Sales Tax, a Transit System that made sense, an Educational System that made sense etc. etc.
Sorry you said? "Sunday Painter Urbanist", that's a new one. Oh, well, at least you apologized.
Why don't you put this one to a poll? Oh, mustn't put the issue to the tyrrany of a majority.
Too bad that the "powers" didn't opt for a breath of fresh air. I was a mere tot when the square opened, and I recall thinking "what a dumb idea" when I looked at the walkways,
and in later years, when walking by the square almost every day, I observed that the walkways fell into disuse. Hopefully, since they're staying for at least another 50 years, the administration will see to it that (a) the walkways are programmed in some meaningful way, and (b) that they are maintained to at least a respectable standard. (Or, can we afford that?).
In one sense, the walkways are symbolic. New City Hall -- the main building, that is -- is a sexy looking thing, but the view of it is obscured to passers by on Queen St. The walkways serve as a "visual chastity belt", blocking the view of something really pretty and other-worldly -- the walkways are a nod to the very prissy Toronto that once was.
The tax base in the 'province of Toronto' would be significantly smaller than the tax base of Ontario as a whole (2.5 million people vs 11 million). Even if it keeps 100% of that tax base you have to also consider what it would lose in terms of economies of scale and in terms of what its share of the larger tax base would have been.