News   Dec 05, 2025
 1K     5 
News   Dec 05, 2025
 3.3K     7 
News   Dec 05, 2025
 620     0 

LCBO / The Beer Store

Should the LCBO be deregulated?


  • Total voters
    169
  • Poll closed .
Here it is...........the deal to avert grocers giving up booze sales en masse.

They will now have the option of paying 'The Beer Store' to accept their empties in exchange for 17c per container.


This deal serves two purposes, first the one above, second, this will slow down the rate of Beer store closures, particularly outside Toronto. This is because it will require, in most cases, the Beer Store to have a take-back location within 10km of the grocery store that sells.

In Toronto, that could be worked out to require only 8 to 10 surviving locations, though they would require dramatically enhanced throughput.

****

As a side note, one very major Beer Store location has been losing money for months, as it does 2x more tacebacks than sales.

This would restore that location to the black ink side of the ledger.

My sense here is that most/all Beer Store locations remain goners as they are, at least in big cities.

But aside from buying time; I expect this will result in a transition where The Beer Store opens takeback only locations that serve no other purpose and are funded by this arrangement.
 
Here it is...........the deal to avert grocers giving up booze sales en masse.

They will now have the option of paying 'The Beer Store' to accept their empties in exchange for 17c per container.


This deal serves two purposes, first the one above, second, this will slow down the rate of Beer store closures, particularly outside Toronto. This is because it will require, in most cases, the Beer Store to have a take-back location within 10km of the grocery store that sells.

In Toronto, that could be worked out to require only 8 to 10 surviving locations, though they would require dramatically enhanced throughput.

****

As a side note, one very major Beer Store location has been losing money for months, as it does 2x more tacebacks than sales.

This would restore that location to the black ink side of the ledger.

My sense here is that most/all Beer Store locations remain goners as they are, at least in big cities.

But aside from buying time; I expect this will result in a transition where The Beer Store opens takeback only locations that serve no other purpose and are funded by this arrangement.
Ah so empties returns are now only for people who have a car (since, for example, if the beer store is only going to have 8-10 locations in Toronto, none of those will be downtown). How very on-brand for a government stuck in (at best) the 1980s.

Also based on that article, are the Retail Council of Canada and the CFIB aware that not everyone owns a car or are they just talking nonsense?
 
Last edited:
Ah so empties returns are now only for people who have a car (since, for example, if the beer store is only going to have 8-10 locations in Toronto, none of those will be downtown). How very on-brand for a government stuck in (at best) the 1980s.

Also based on that article, are the Retail Council of Canada and the CFIB aware that not everyone owns a car or are they just talking nonsense?
Return locations don’t have to be limited to Beer Store outlets. It’s entirely feasible to establish them at other sites, such as gas stations to fill a gap if needed (as is already available in many places across the province, particularily where they've already closed stores).

See: Where to return empties.
 
Return locations don’t have to be limited to Beer Store outlets. It’s entirely feasible to establish them at other sites, such as gas stations to fill a gap if needed (as is already available in many places across the province, particularily where they've already closed stores).
Agreed, but this is *Ontario* and we can't do that. The same model that works globally, and in other provinces cannot work here
 
Agreed, but this is *Ontario* and we can't do that. The same model that works globally, and in other provinces cannot work here
Did you misread?

We do this today in Ontario. Click my link above..you'll see many return locations that are not Beer Stores. In fact I have one in my neck of the woods that's at a gas station.

Heres another example (Haliburton). 1 beer store with many additional drop off locations:

Screenshot_20251126_222009.jpg
 
Did you misread?

We do this today in Ontario. Click my link above..you'll see many return locations that are not Beer Stores. In fact I have one in my neck of the woods that's at a gas station.

Heres another example (Haliburton). 1 beer store with many additional drop off locations:

View attachment 699152
I do not misread. Other places have returns at *every* supermarket. This isn't rocket science. And I'm talking about major cities.

Edit to add: this is my area. The closest one is 3+ km away. That is *not* convenient
1000040210.jpg
 
Return locations don’t have to be limited to Beer Store outlets. It’s entirely feasible to establish them at other sites, such as gas stations to fill a gap if needed (as is already available in many places across the province, particularily where they've already closed stores).

See: Where to return empties.
While I hope they can establish them at other sites, it's worth noting there are also very few gas stations in downtown Toronto either, nor are gas stations often located at places that are primarily accessible by walking, which was my main point. I don't see gas stations suddenly making an effort to accommodate those without cars just to accept empties. As a person without a car, where are the options for me?

For context, I used to return all my empties to the Beer Store on Church north of Wellesley, then they steadily closed most of the stores in the area I could walk my returns to. So now I just put them in the recycling, because it would cost me more to get a car than it's worth to recycle some wine bottles. I have no other use for a car. Not sure how a gas station (unless they specifically force the one at Jarvis and Wellesley to accept empties) would help me.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: PL1
It will be interesting to see how it shakes out in the rural areas where beer stores have already closed. I did a couple of random checks of communities I know and one has the nearest return location 47 km away and another with several but outside of the 10km goal.
 
It will be interesting to see how it shakes out in the rural areas where beer stores have already closed. I did a couple of random checks of communities I know and one has the nearest return location 47 km away and another with several but outside of the 10km goal.
People are just going to eat the cost and recycle or throw them in the garbage
 
I do not misread. Other places have returns at *every* supermarket. This isn't rocket science. And I'm talking about major cities.
Got it. But at least they could open other locations, as I suggested. It should be possible to establish additional drop‑off sites dedicated solely to returns.

While I hope they can establish them at other sites, it's worth noting there are also very few gas stations in downtown Toronto either, nor are gas stations often located at places that are primarily accessible by walking, which was my main point. I don't see gas stations suddenly making an effort to accommodate those without cars just to accept empties. As a person without a car, where are the options for me?
...
The gas station is just an example, not a requirement. There are plenty of places across the province that accept returns which aren’t gas stations. In my Haliburton example above, there are convenience stores, shopping centres, and other sites.

The point stands: it’s entirely possible, as already done in other parts of Ontario. Where Beer Stores have closed, I expect at least some convenient drop‑off locations to be maintained so that service levels remain relatively consistent.
 

Back
Top