News   Sep 30, 2022
 3.7K     1 
News   Sep 30, 2022
 3.3K     7 
News   Sep 30, 2022
 1.3K     0 

U of T: University College Revitalization (Renovation, Kohn Shnier + ERA)

UtakataNoAnnex

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Mar 5, 2020
Messages
4,019
Reaction score
5,523
It appears they've rewired everything for the high tech, hence influencing a lot of the design choices for good or bad. But I agree that in doing so, they left some components here that are not like the others. >.<
 

AlbertC

Superstar
Member Bio
Joined
Apr 24, 2007
Messages
19,242
Reaction score
46,521
Location
Davenport
From ERA's website:



231-KSARC-University-College-1-768x576.jpg
012-KSARC-University-College-768x576.jpg
136-KSARC-University-College-768x576.jpg
361-KSARC-University-College-768x566.jpg
127-KSARC-University-College-768x576.jpg
172-KSARC-University-College-768x576.jpg
 

Northern Light

Superstar
Member Bio
Joined
May 20, 2007
Messages
21,250
Reaction score
51,620
Location
Toronto/EY
Definitely not my idea of a style that complements UC..

AoD

Agree completely.

I find it disappointing and disrespectful to the heritage of UC.

Fortunately most of the changes are not of a permanent nature but paint/stain/furnishing etc.
 

Northern Light

Superstar
Member Bio
Joined
May 20, 2007
Messages
21,250
Reaction score
51,620
Location
Toronto/EY

I viscerally dislike this project; and I was one of the people who suggested moving the library back to its original home.

I just feel the job done here is incredibly off-key and disrespectful to the heritage space. It's really rather gutting to see good money spent to make something worse.
 

Nastapoka

Active Member
Member Bio
Joined
Apr 2, 2015
Messages
113
Reaction score
137
I viscerally dislike this project; and I was one of the people who suggested moving the library back to its original home.

I just feel the job done here is incredibly off-key and disrespectful to the heritage space. It's really rather gutting to see good money spent to make something worse.
"Disrespectful" to a style needs to be retired from architectural discourse. It is truly meaningless.
 

whatever

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Nov 25, 2007
Messages
2,856
Reaction score
908
If architecture is a discourse about style what would even be left if you banned the idea that architectural styles might be in a dialogue with each other? And that that dialogue could either be harmonious or not?
 

Nastapoka

Active Member
Member Bio
Joined
Apr 2, 2015
Messages
113
Reaction score
137
If architecture is a discourse about style what would even be left if you banned the idea that architectural styles might be in a dialogue with each other? And that that dialogue could either be harmonious or not?
Harmony sure. But the idea of styles being "disrespectful" is just tired trad nonsense.
 

whatever

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Nov 25, 2007
Messages
2,856
Reaction score
908
You'd prefer we all just either defer to acclaim or reduce our commentary to "I like that" or "I don't like that"?

That sounds more detrimental to the discourse than the word "disrespectful", but maybe I'm insufficiently posttrad?
 

isaidso

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
May 23, 2007
Messages
1,966
Reaction score
2,029
I viscerally dislike this project; and I was one of the people who suggested moving the library back to its original home.

I just feel the job done here is incredibly off-key and disrespectful to the heritage space. It's really rather gutting to see good money spent to make something worse.

I have the exact same reaction to this project. They tried turning it into something it is not. Juxtaposition of old and new can result in something wonderful. In other cases one needs to work with what you're given or risk ruining it. If this building no longer works as a modern library you move the library somewhere else... like you suggested.

Instead, they forced an aesthetic that doesn't belong here. Employing expensive, quality modernity doesn't distract from the fact that they've wrecked what was a beautiful historic interior. What they've done to it is an affront. Hopefully, they haven't done too much damage and it can one day be restored.
 
Last edited:

UtakataNoAnnex

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Mar 5, 2020
Messages
4,019
Reaction score
5,523
"Disrespectful" to a style needs to be retired from architectural discourse. It is truly meaningless.
Visually though it still has relevance, IMO. Especially when the newer elements here seem to be screaming "Look at me!" /sigh
 

AlvinofDiaspar

Moderator
Member Bio
Joined
Apr 22, 2007
Messages
31,944
Reaction score
25,547
Location
Toronto
Visually though it still has relevance, IMO. Especially when the newer elements here seem to be screaming "Look at me!" /sigh

The problem is partly it isn’t great look at me - certainly not when compared to what was there. The whole ensemble felt extremely heavy-handed for the context.

AoD
 

Top