I count 60 in service this year (4458 to 4517 inclusive) from January 6 2018 to December 31, 2018.
4 cars short. They did miss the in-service target of 64 - though they had 4 more cars (4518 to 4520 and 4572) received but not in service at year end. Along with 4521 unloaded today.
Close enough to their 2018 schedule for me. But the lack of Kingston cars is concerning. They only need 80 more cars manufactured (plus 4401 which is being completed in Quebec). With them delivering 61 cars from Thunder Bay in 2018, then the remaining 47 cars from there seem to be easy enough.
Can they produce 33 more cars in Kingston this year? I think that's going to be the weak point.
You also forgot every Flexity up to 4467 which all have to go back for welding.. that will go to 2022/2023.