News   Oct 18, 2021
 194     0 
News   Oct 18, 2021
 565     0 
News   Oct 15, 2021
 2.8K     3 

TTC: Flexity Streetcars Testing & Delivery (Bombardier)

crs1026

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Oct 16, 2014
Messages
7,331
Reaction score
11,062
I’m pretty sure that in one of the recovery plans, La Pocatiere was to be used to do more of the initial fabrications, stuff that Mexico was having such trouble with. Whereas Thunder Bay has assembly capability only, using parts that are shipped in.

So it may have been a case of taking the car to the parts maker as opposed to shipping the parts to the assembly plant.

Since the Thunder Bay is now in full stride, at least relative to the early days, it might not make much sense to disrupt that production line and/or tie up floor space with a specialty task.

- Paul
 

dowlingm

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
May 7, 2007
Messages
3,780
Reaction score
1,617
I’m pretty sure that in one of the recovery plans, La Pocatiere was to be used to do more of the initial fabrications, stuff that Mexico was having such trouble with. Whereas Thunder Bay has assembly capability only, using parts that are shipped in.

So it may have been a case of taking the car to the parts maker as opposed to shipping the parts to the assembly plant.

Since the Thunder Bay is now in full stride, at least relative to the early days, it might not make much sense to disrupt that production line and/or tie up floor space with a specialty task.
Let's assume, given how long it took 4400/4402 to return that there is a lot more going on than ramp replacement, which surely could have been done at the Barns anyway.

Maybe the process will be that La P will do disassembly then ship 4401 in "kit form", possibly along with La P manufactured parts, to be reassembled on TB's line. This does not tie up either of TB's lines or other floor space to do the disassembly but may take advantage of floor space available (for whatever reason in La P).

Alternatively, the attractive factor may be the availability of skilled workers in La P pending the ramp up to the new Azur order (rather than the floor space)? [EDIT: there could be pressure on BBD to use La P for Quebec City trams if BBD gets that work, so it works on a familiarisation basis also]
 

cplchanb

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Apr 15, 2010
Messages
2,114
Reaction score
1,215
Let's assume, given how long it took 4400/4402 to return that there is a lot more going on than ramp replacement, which surely could have been done at the Barns anyway.

Maybe the process will be that La P will do disassembly then ship 4401 in "kit form", possibly along with La P manufactured parts, to be reassembled on TB's line. This does not tie up either of TB's lines or other floor space to do the disassembly but may take advantage of floor space available (for whatever reason in La P).

Alternatively, the attractive factor may be the availability of skilled workers in La P pending the ramp up to the new Azur order (rather than the floor space)? [EDIT: there could be pressure on BBD to use La P for Quebec City trams if BBD gets that work, so it works on a familiarisation basis also]

If that's the case I wonder if it's more economical just to renumber one of the new cars as 4401 and eventually have the usable original components recycled into the production line as another car
 

dowlingm

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
May 7, 2007
Messages
3,780
Reaction score
1,617
If that's the case I wonder if it's more economical just to renumber one of the new cars as 4401 and eventually have the usable original components recycled into the production line as another car
I suspect TTC would have a problem with cars coming other than “as new” for the purposes of tracking mileage. BBD could have used pre prod cars as demonstrators but the odd width of TTC cars would make them only suitable for SEPTA, and they are possibly too tall for them
 

cplchanb

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Apr 15, 2010
Messages
2,114
Reaction score
1,215
I suspect TTC would have a problem with cars coming other than “as new” for the purposes of tracking mileage. BBD could have used pre prod cars as demonstrators but the odd width of TTC cars would make them only suitable for SEPTA, and they are possibly too tall for them

I guess I should rephrase: I was referring to new cars coming off the line. Have the next new car be 4401 and filter off the salvagable used parts to piece together a 45xx
 

cplchanb

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Apr 15, 2010
Messages
2,114
Reaction score
1,215

SaugeenJunction

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Jan 23, 2014
Messages
2,167
Reaction score
3,882
This is very unscientific and I am sure that there are other designs, and that a TTC unit may be different, but I've compiled some notable examples from each of the 10 supplier's models for your viewing pleasure. And yes, I wonder who made the shortlist, and where the new barn to accommodate the units will be located.

A5xvdou.png


gezCSif.png

4RYBw3g.png

xLMFXzP.png

fzxbo7e.png
 

innsertnamehere

Superstar
Member Bio
Joined
Mar 8, 2010
Messages
15,899
Reaction score
12,573
The report essentially says "sure we can pick someone other than Bombardier but their costs are going to be way higher and take years longer".
 

bbdfollower

New Member
Member Bio
Joined
Oct 20, 2017
Messages
53
Reaction score
40
the timeline in that document has 'contract award' in Q4 2020, and first delivery out in Q2 2024.

But, once all of the 204 initial-order cars are delivered, presumably sometime in Q4 2019 or Q1 2020, couldn't we immediately start having cars from the option-order delivered? 2019 production schedule is 83 cars to be delivered - if they can achieve that rate, or even 60-70% we could conceivably have another 100 cars here by Q3 2021?
 

Voltz

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Jan 26, 2008
Messages
1,674
Reaction score
527
the timeline in that document has 'contract award' in Q4 2020, and first delivery out in Q2 2024.

But, once all of the 204 initial-order cars are delivered, presumably sometime in Q4 2019 or Q1 2020, couldn't we immediately start having cars from the option-order delivered? 2019 production schedule is 83 cars to be delivered - if they can achieve that rate, or even 60-70% we could conceivably have another 100 cars here by Q3 2021?

They could have done that if they exercised the option in the Bombardier order, but there was too much political posturing against them to do that,
 

bbdfollower

New Member
Member Bio
Joined
Oct 20, 2017
Messages
53
Reaction score
40
They could have done that if they exercised the option in the Bombardier order, but there was too much political posturing against them to do that,

So the option is expired? If the option is expired, why do they mention the strike price of cars in this report: that should be completely irrelevant to what we can expect to pay on the open market right now.
 

rbt

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Apr 25, 2007
Messages
6,890
Reaction score
2,711
The report essentially says "sure we can pick someone other than Bombardier but their costs are going to be way higher and take years longer".

Yep, but I'm seeing a requirements for about 160 additional vehicles total.

1) Staff want to take the Bombardier option for 60 with expectations that they can be fully delivered by 2021.

2) Staff want to buy an 100 additional units (the long way) with delivery from 2024 through ~2036.

It would be nice if both happened. I don't expect to see any provincial funding for it though.
 

cplchanb

Senior Member
Member Bio
Joined
Apr 15, 2010
Messages
2,114
Reaction score
1,215
This is very unscientific and I am sure that there are other designs, and that a TTC unit may be different, but I've compiled some notable examples from each of the 10 supplier's models for your viewing pleasure. And yes, I wonder who made the shortlist, and where the new barn to accommodate the units will be located.

wow CRRC is so big they could afford to send 3 different divisions to bid for the same project....
 

Top