News   Nov 08, 2024
 433     0 
News   Nov 08, 2024
 882     3 
News   Nov 08, 2024
 476     0 

Rome-Born Architect Dreams of Completing Colosseum

D

dan e 1980

Guest
Rome-Born Architect Dreams of Completing Colosseum
Mon Mar 8,11:30 AM ET


By Claire Soares

ROME (Reuters) - The Colosseum will come full circle if one septuagenarian Roman gets his way.


Reuters Photo
mdf491160.jpg



Architect Carlo Aymonino wants to rebuild the outer wall of the world's most famous amphitheater, once rocked by earthquakes and quarried to build other glories in the Eternal City.


"It wouldn't be an Italian Disneyland. In fact it would be the exact opposite -- a careful scientifically correct reconstruction," the 78-year-old told Reuters in an interview.


His planned revamp could well become the next chapter in a long and often bitter debate about whether archaeological and artistic wonders should be left to succumb to the effects of time or be restored to their original beauty.


The recent staging of pop concerts and art exhibitions in the Colosseum, where once the baying Roman mob feasted on gory gladiatorial battles, is proof that time for Italy's treasures has not stood still.


Sitting in his studio, surrounded by sketches and models, the softly spoken Aymonino had more ammunition to use against those arguing for a hands-off approach to antiquity.


"The Colosseum now has an electronically operated lift which the Romans certainly didn't," he said with a wink.


Slaves sweated and toiled for about eight years to build the original Colosseum, which was inaugurated in 80 AD with a 100-day festival of ferocious warfare.


But Aymonino is unfazed by the thought of rebuilding the outer wall of Italy's most visited archaeological site, which attracts almost three million tourists a year.


"It wouldn't take much, you could use brick," he said.


UNDOING MUSSOLINI


Aymonino also wants to pull up the road built by 20th-century Fascist dictator Benito Mussolini, which carves a path straight through the Roman Forum.


"It's ridiculous, that street. They covered up lots of ruins and split the Forum in two," he sighed, adding that he doesn't buy the argument that removing the thoroughfare would gridlock an already-congested city.


"Traffic, like water, always finds a way," he said.


With the sites reunited, the bespectacled white-haired architect wants to rebuild ruins like the Temple of Mars, which hosted solemn religious ceremonies before being turned into a museum of art.


"The three surviving upright columns are beautiful but there are bases of many more. So why not put them back up, making them smooth not ridged to distinguish the old from the new?"


And then, he says, it's time to inject some vitality.





"We don't need streets of shops but why not have the odd bookshop and cafe dotted around ... something that gives an idea of how lively it might have been?"

Aymonino gives no figure for the cost of realizing his dream, but his fundraising ideas may stoke controversy.

"It would be a good thing for someone like Coca-Cola to fund in terms of publicity. They could ... tell the whole world that they'd completed the Colosseum."

He will hand his plans to Rome's mayor on April 21, the anniversary of the city's foundation. Then it's wait and see.

But modern-day visitors seem as averse to the idea of reconstructing the Colosseum as 19th-century novelist Charles Dickens, who declared "God be thanked: a ruin!"

"If there was a risk that the Colosseum would fall down or disintegrate then that would be a different matter. I think the original structure should be conserved," said Alex Wenham, a 26-year-old English stonemason.

And Lisa Goldscheider, a London lawyer, agreed.

"It's amazing it's still standing. Maybe it's best not to play with history."
 
Leave the original- he should perform his personal 'experiment' elsewhere. Sounds like a monumental waste of time.
 
If you want to see a near-prefectly preserved arena (Colosseum) which is still used for concerts and is used by the city's symphony, visit Verona.

Leave Rome's Colosseum as is. What next, rebuild the entire forum?
 
There's one in Pula in Croatia that's still in pretty good shape as well.
 
I fully support any effort to maintain and stabilize the current condition of the Coliseum. To rebuild it though would be to replace history. If he wants to build an exact replica, he can do that elsewhere.
 
They built a road through the Forum?! We really should stop going on about how we destroy our heritage and Europe doesn't. They just have so much more to destroy!
 
Yes, leave the original the way it is an build an exact replica with equal materials, scale, and detail in the port lands.
 
next thing you know, he'll demand the lions be brought back and that people be fed to them at least once a week.

i could just imagine.

todays show *man vs. three lions" brought to you by coca~cola.

that place is a "ground zero" where many Christians, Jews, even romans, people in general, animals, etc. have been slaughtered and ripped to shreds for the sole purpose of entertainment. i agree with preserving it as a testament to those who died but not to rebuild it to it's gory glory days.

what's next? rebuild nazi headquarters? brought to you by Pepsi?
 
"Colosseum- A Gladiator's Story" will be on Discovery Channel this Sunday at 9pm. It's a special program with very realistic computer-generated graphics.
 
I think it should be rebuilt. The history I am interested in is that of the living, active ancient Rome -- not the various earthquakes that have struck it over the years. My interests would best be served by something more integrated into the city (but certainly not a theme park type venue).

Really, what is more historical -- ruins or something like the original?
 
So you guys dont agree with the restorations of the Sphynix? I think its honorable to try and want to rebuild these ancient masterpeices to their former glory.

I think this is one of the fundamental differences between Europe and North America. My parents noticed this when watching Antiques Roadshow, all North Americans see the value in antiques that are scratched and ruined, that brings up their value, while in Europe no one would even want something like that in their house, it would be embarrassing. In Europe restored peices go for much higher prices, especially if the restoration respects the original work. I see a very clear parallel to the Colosseum in this regard.
 
I don't think the Colosseum should be rebuilt. It has been standing as a ruin for so long that it's the ruin itself that is the landmark building, and it's the ruin that is the tourist attraction. It stands as a testimony to all the periods of history that it's been through, and that's why people visit it.

However, I do support the reconstruction of buildings that have been crumbled so far that it's unrecognizable. That's what they've done at Mayan ruins like Chichen Itza and Uxmal in Mexico (near Cancun). Rebuilding a building that's crumbled to rubble would not only give people an idea of what was there originally, but it would also help archaeologists determine how these buildings were built. It also helps you get tourist dollars (as the Mexicans have learned). People don't go see piles of rubble... people want to see buildings, or at least some ruins that resemble buildings.

*****

Let's think closer to home. Should Detroit be rebuilt? :)
 
I think we should bring this guy to Toronto. Maybe he can get the Bay Adelaide Centre finished. Though I think he'd have more luck with the Colosseum.
 

Back
Top