Tunnelling is not the lion's share of the overall build of the new line. Station construction is equally as complex and time consuming. For reference, the Eglinton crosstown west extension finished tunnelling in June 2025 (project broke ground in March 2022), but with station construction just starting we're still only expecting completion by 2029 or 2030.
Station construction for the Ontario line has the added issue of having 35m deep stations in the downtown section which is much more difficult to build than the shallow Eglinton West stations. Also, space is not a concern for the Eglinton West stations vs downtown for the Ontario Line. The good thing for the Ontario Line is that we're already well on our way to build the stations for the line. The only hassle being that the TBMs will have to be dis-assembled and re-assembled when it reaches each of the already excavated stations further increasing the total tunnelling time.
Also, rest assured that according to my research, another 2 TBMs will be used to tunnel the Pape avenue portion of the line:
Metrolinx press release
It is clear though, that the opening date for the OL will inevitably push back from the current 2031 date to at least 2033 or later, which is a shame. All of the money being thrown at this project and yet it will be both over budget and delayed.