Hamilton 2900 King Street East | 69.2m | 20s | Camarro Group | RAW Design

www.thespec.com

Ontario Land Tribunal rejects ‘massive’ towers by Stoney Creek’s Battlefield Park

The Ontario Land Tribunal has rejected a local developer’s bid to build 18- and 20-storey residential towers on a grassy lot near Stoney Creek’s Battlefield park, ruling they would be a “jarring” change to the neighbourhood’s character.
www.thespec.com www.thespec.com

In siding with the city, tribunal member Tee Fung Ng likened the “massive” twin towers to “the highest mountains in an area of small hills,” with the tallest building’s 65-metre height more than four times the commercially zoned lot’s 14-metre limit.

The proposed towers are too close to the property line and their “sudden height, density, and scale” would overwhelm Battlefield park, views of the escarpment and the area’s landscape of low- and mid-rise buildings, Fung wrote in a May 3 ruling.
Click to expand...
 
innsertnamehere said:
Oof. Second loss in as many weeks for UrbanSolutions.

The right decision here as it was at Winona Gardens, but still.
Click to expand...

I would like to hear you elaborate on this take if you would.

I'm interested in why you feel this was the right decision here (I'm not disagreeing, just asking).
 
Northern Light said:
I would like to hear you elaborate on this take if you would.

I'm interested in why you feel this was the right decision here (I'm not disagreeing, just asking).
Click to expand...
It's not nearly as big an offender as the Winona project, but it's a lot of density in a location which doesn't exactly have great walkability or transit. It would be better to focus density down along Highway 8, closer to the LRT and amenities within walking distance.
 
innsertnamehere said:
It's not nearly as big an offender as the Winona project, but it's a lot of density in a location which doesn't exactly have great walkability or transit. It would be better to focus density down along Highway 8, closer to the LRT and amenities within walking distance.
Click to expand...

Not just that but reenactments happen of the battle of stoney creek every year and to see that rise up in the distance is not something that they would accept as fitting in with the character of it - the plot also contains the remains of loyalist soldiers in the cemetery and most likely some spill out into here - the city should probably just designate it as heritage and make it a park or something.

across the street father down there used to be a doctors office that burned down - when they went to rebuild it they discovered remains of soldiers and thus were not allowed to rebuild anything on the plot - this is a sensitive area.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to post here.

Back
Top