Over the course of the day, I've been pondering over what these'll be replacing, i.e. the "lozenge", the curved rectangle. True, the old "profiled" logo signs a la Davisville yard are definitely cherishable, but the lozenge (more of a 60s B-D era thing) is epigrammatic--and unsung. (And I'm deliberately writing this off the top of my head, without referring to Transit Toronto whether they've anything written on the subject.) And I noticed these three types at St. Patrick...
First, there's the "classic" lozenge. Moulded plastic within a metal frame, perched upon a stainless steel pole or hung from a right-angled curved version of the same. (There's even a sort of harmony between the lozenge shape and the form of a transit vehicle, or the Y-U-S line looping around Union, etc.) Within the lozenge is, in classic red + cream, the TTC "SUBWAY" logo, i.e. with the TTC letters in the top of the shield, and the overlaid horizontal ribbon inscribed with SUBWAY. Simple, elegant, and effective.
Then, a step down from that, there's the post-1980, i.e. "post-cream" version, where it's a standard generic red + white-era TTC logo, no overlaid "subway" ribbon or anything. But the general form of the sign--even down to the moulded plastic--remains more or less the same.
And a step down from *that* is the version with the generic logo *and* the lackluster mixed-case Arial "Subway" below it. And it's now a flat plastic panel, no moulding, no 3-dimensionality. Even the latter-day stainless steel supports seem like pale, spindly shadows of the originals (to say nothing of the "hanging" version where clumsy perpendiculars replace the right-angled arc).
Compared to all this, while the new-version graphics are good, the mode of display--a rectangular light box on a pole--is more banal than it could be. And it's definitely an improvement over what the lozenge has became over the past quarter century; relative to the original, though, it's ambivalent at best (except maybe from a graphic/readability standpoint; but, ought not the symbol be enough? While we love to worship the classic subway font, it doesn't mean we *must* fetishistically use it each and every time...)
Okay, now. Now that I've written that, I'd better check Transit Toronto and see how whatever they have to say compares to my current off-the-cuff sizing-up...